Quick guides for the hard moments. Each one starts with what to do right now, then explains why it happens, what to say and how to make the next time less likely.
How to use these guides
Find your situation in the list below and read the Right now box first: it is written for the moment itself. The rest (why it happens, things to say, prevention and when to get help) is for later, once things have settled.
Every guide builds on the best-proven approach and links to the matching cards in the Toolbox. The age chips under each title show which ages a guide fits, and By age has more for each stage.
First aid for any hard moment
Whichever guide you need, the first minute is the same.
Safety first. If anyone could get hurt, deal with that before anything else: move your child, or hold them calmly (see safe holds).
Calm yourself, then your child. Take a breath and lower your voice. Yelling at or shaming children, the American Academy of Pediatrics (2018) says in its policy statement, is minimally effective in the short term and not effective in the long term.78
Use few words. Say one short, calm sentence, then stop.
Deal with it later. Save the teaching, talking and problem-solving for when everyone is calm enough to listen.
Respond the same way every time. Across the 77 program evaluations Kaminski et al. (2008) pooled, the programs that taught time-out and the importance of consistent parenting had larger effects.11
Nearly all preschoolers have tantrums sometimes,143 so in the moment your job is not to stop the storm but to keep everyone safe, stay calm and hold the limit.
Check for safety first. Move your child away from anything hard or sharp, and move breakables and other children out of reach.
Take a slow breath, keep your voice low and say very little: name the feeling and the limit once, then stop talking. Save reasons for later.
Hold the limit. Don’t give in to whatever started it, and don’t argue, bargain or lecture. Staying calm and quiet nearby is planned ignoring of the tantrum, not of your child.
Stay close. Some children want a hug or your lap (time-in); others need a little space with you in sight. Both are fine.
When it’s over, welcome your child back warmly and move on. No lecture now; talk later if you need to. If you lost your temper too, see repair after conflict.
Why it happens
Tantrums are a normal part of early childhood. When Wakschlag et al. (2012) asked the parents of 1,490 preschoolers in a community sample, 83.7% of the children had tantrums at least sometimes, but only 8.6% had them every day.143 Ordinary tantrums tend to be frustration boiling over in situations you could almost predict.143 Think of hearing no, having to stop something fun or a toy that won’t work.
Tired, stressed children have less self-control to draw on. Diamond (2013), reviewing the research on executive functions, the mental skills that include self-control, notes that stress and lack of sleep each impair them.94 The tired, rushed moments are the ones to watch.
Once a tantrum starts, holding the limit calmly matters. Leijten et al. (2018) combined experiments on single parenting behaviors in a meta-analysis and found that briefly withdrawing attention after a child refused to do what was asked increased cooperation.45 Stay close and kind, then, but don’t let the tantrum change the answer. If tantrums come with hitting or running off, see aggression and dangerous behavior in the best-proven approach.
Things you can say
You’re really angry. I’m right here.
The answer is still no. I’ll stay with you until you feel better.
Do you want a hug, or should I just sit here with you?
I’m moving the blocks so nobody gets hurt.
That was a big feeling, and you got through it. Let’s get some water.
Preventing the next one
Notice when tantrums tend to happen (tired, hungry, rushed, a sudden change of plan) and plan around the hardest times of day. With a toddler, step in early with redirection before frustration boils over.
Protect sleep. In its 2016 consensus statement, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommends 11-14 hours per 24 hours at ages 1-2 and 10-13 hours at ages 3-5, naps included, and links regularly getting enough sleep with better behavior and emotional regulation.161
Give a heads-up before changes (“Five more minutes, then bath”) and try offering choices you’re happy with either way.
Catch the calm moments and say so. Leijten et al. (2019) found only 3 of 26 techniques linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior across their meta-analyses of parenting program trials, and positive reinforcement, praise in particular, was one of them.16
Spend a few minutes a day in connection time, playing what your child chooses. Kaminski et al. (2008) found in their meta-analysis that parenting programs which built positive parent-child interaction had larger effects.11
On a calm day, make a calm-down plan with your preschooler or older child.
When to get help
Tantrums are often unpredictable (out of the blue), very long or destructive. Wakschlag et al. (2012) found in a large study that temper loss of clinical concern tended to look like this, rather than like a reaction to everyday frustration.143
During tantrums, your child hurts themselves or is often violent toward people or things. Belden et al. (2008) found these behaviors more common in preschoolers with depression or disruptive behavior disorders than in healthy preschoolers.89
Your child has many tantrums at preschool or daycare, not just at home, or has a very hard time recovering afterward. In the same study, both were more common in preschoolers with disruptive behavior disorders than in healthy ones.89
Tantrums are getting more frequent or more intense as your child gets older, or they get in the way of family life, preschool or friendships.
You feel close to losing control yourself. That’s a reason to get support, not a failure: see help lines.
A meltdown in a store or restaurant is a tantrum with an audience: handle it the way you would at home, somewhere quieter if you can, and let the onlookers look.
Safety first. Near roads, parking lots or crowds, hold your child’s hand or pick them up and move somewhere safe.
Focus on your child, not the onlookers. You don’t owe anyone an explanation.
Move somewhere quieter if you can: a corner, outside, or your parked car with you beside them.
Say the limit once, calmly. Don’t buy the thing or strike a new deal to stop the noise.
Stay close and wait it out, as you would at home: the crying gets no reaction (planned ignoring), and you stay calmly beside your child (time-in). See tantrums.
If it won’t settle, it’s fine to leave. Ending the outing early is a fair logical consequence, and it takes the pressure off you too.
Why it happens
A meltdown in public is usually the same tantrum you see at home, with two extra pressures: the place is full of things your child wants, and you feel watched. Being watched can pull parents toward ending it fast, either by giving in or by getting harsh. Harshness is not the shortcut it looks like: in its 2018 policy statement, the American Academy of Pediatrics calls yelling at or shaming children minimally effective in the short term and not effective in the long term.78
Your best bet is to do what you would do at home. Kaminski et al. (2008) pooled 77 evaluations of parenting programs and found larger effects for the programs that taught time-out and the importance of consistent parenting.11 Consistent, here, means the answer in the store is the same as the answer at home, even with people watching.
Sometimes the outing itself is the problem: too long, too loud, too close to nap time. Leaving early is not losing; it gives everyone a fresh start. For more, see public places in the best-proven approach.
Things you can say
I know you really want it. It’s not coming home with us today.
We’re going outside until you feel calmer. I’m staying right here with you.
Hold my hand or ride in the cart. You pick.
You calmed your body down. Thank you. Let’s finish up together.
We left the park early because the yelling didn’t stop. We’ll try again another day.
Preventing the next one
Go when your child is rested and fed, keep trips short, and bring a snack and something to do.
Before you go in, say the plan and one or two rules in simple words: “We’re buying milk and rice, not toys. Stay next to the cart.” See clear expectations and instructions.
Give your child a job: holding the list, choosing between two apples, putting things in the cart. See redirection.
Notice good behavior while it’s happening: “You’re walking right next to me. That really helps.” Leijten et al. (2019) found praise among the few techniques linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior in their meta-analyses of parenting program trials.16
Use when-then for the fun part: “When we’ve paid, then we can go to the playground.”
Practice on short, easy trips you can leave without losing much before trying a long one.
When to get help
Meltdowns happen almost everywhere you go, are getting worse rather than better, or you have started avoiding outings because of them.
Your child often bolts toward traffic or into crowds. See dangerous behavior.
Noise and crowds seem to overwhelm your child again and again, or you have other questions about their development, such as speech, play or how they connect with people. Raise it at a checkup, and see developmental differences.
You notice any of the warning signs listed under tantrums.
Most toddlers hit, bite or push at times,137 and for most children it fades as they grow,92 so respond the same calm way every time: stop it, comfort the child who was hurt, and follow with a brief consequence.
Step in straight away. Calmly hold your child’s hands or move them out of reach, and say one short line: “No hitting. Hitting hurts.” See safe holds.
Turn to the child who was hurt first and comfort them. The hurt child gets your attention before the one who hit.
Follow with the same brief consequence every time: for a toddler, a short break away from the play with you nearby; for an older child, a short time-out or losing the toy or game for a while. If a toddler goes straight back to it, my toddler keeps testing limits shows how to make the break stick.
Keep your voice calm and your words few. No long lecture.
Never hit, bite or pinch back to show how it feels. The reasons are below.
Once everyone is calm, help your child make amends if they can: checking on the other child, fetching a cold cloth, helping rebuild the tower. See repair after conflict.
Why it happens
Physical aggression is a normal stage of early childhood, not a sign of a bad child. Among the 2,253 young children Alink et al. (2006) studied, physical aggression already appeared at 12 months, was more common at 24 and 36 months, and declined from the third birthday onward.86 Côté et al. (2006) followed 10,658 Canadian children between ages 2 and 11: most used physical aggression occasionally or rarely as toddlers and rarely or almost never by pre-adolescence, while about 1 in 6 (16.6%) stayed on a high, stable path.92
What helps is a calm response that is the same every time. Kaminski et al. (2008) pooled 77 program evaluations, and the parenting programs that taught time-out and consistent parenting had larger effects.11 Two small studies point the same way. Mace et al. (1986) used brief time-out with 3 children, 2 of whom had intellectual disabilities, and aggression and disruption fell.48 In a classroom, Reynolds and Kelley (1997) had each aggressive act cost a smiley face (with a short reprimand), while keeping at least one face earned a reward, and aggression dropped substantially in the 4 preschoolers.55 For the full plan, see aggression in the best-proven approach.
Hitting or biting a child back to show how it feels can seem logical. But when Gershoff (2002) pooled the studies of parental corporal punishment, it was associated with more immediate compliance and also with more aggression in children,66 and, in its 2018 policy statement, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that adults not hit children at all.78 A minority of researchers, Larzelere et al. (2024) among them, argue that the harmful-looking results for ordinary spanking are likely due to other differences between families that the studies could not fully control.74Physical discipline sets out both sides, and also takes up the belief that children who are hit grow up more disciplined.
Things you can say
No hitting. I won’t let you hurt anyone.
You’re mad. You can stomp your feet or squeeze this pillow. You can’t hit.
Teeth are for food, not for people.
Hitting means a break from the game. You can come back when your hands are ready to be gentle.
Let’s check on your brother. What could help him feel better?
Preventing the next one
Watch for the build-up (crowded play, a tired afternoon, a fight over a toy) and step in early with redirection or a different toy.
When everyone is calm, teach what to do instead: say stop, walk away, get a grown-up, stomp, squeeze a pillow. Practice it in play.
Notice gentle play out loud: “You asked for a turn. That was kind.” When Leijten et al. (2019) pooled parenting program trials, praise was among the few techniques linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior.16
Agree on the same rule and the same consequence with everyone who cares for your child: the other parent, grandparents, childcare. See grandparents with different rules.
When to get help
Hitting or biting is frequent and not easing as your child gets older, or it is getting worse. Most children use physical aggression less as they grow, but in the large Canadian study by Côté et al. (2006), about 1 in 6 stayed on a high, stable path.92
Someone is getting hurt: real injuries, aggression toward babies or pets, or your child’s preschool or daycare is raising concerns.
Aggression comes with other worries about development, such as speech, play or getting along with others. See developmental differences.
You have used a consistent plan for several weeks and nothing has changed. See when it is not working.
If anyone is being hurt, step in and separate them first. Safety comes before fairness.
Give each child a calm spot apart for a few minutes, with no blame yet.
Don’t try to work out who started it in the heat of the moment.
If they’re fighting over something, put it out of reach for now: “The truck takes a break until you two have a plan.”
If someone hit, use your usual consequence for hitting, whoever did it. See hitting and biting.
Once everyone is calm, sit down for solving problems together: each child says what happened and how they feel, then they suggest ideas and pick one to try. If someone got hurt, this is also the time to make amends: see repair after conflict.
Why it happens
Siblings share space, toys and their parents’ attention, so disagreements come with the territory. Hurting each other is a different matter. Tucker et al. (2013) drew on a national sample of 3,599 children and youth: those who had experienced sibling aggression in the past year (psychological, property or physical) reported more mental health distress, and among children up to age 9, even mild physical assault was linked with more distress than among older youth.139 That is reason enough to take it seriously.
With coaching, children can learn to sort out conflicts themselves. Siddiqui and Ross (2004) trained mothers of 5- to 8-year-olds to mediate their children’s disputes, and compared with children in control families, these children reasoned, talked about feelings and understood each other’s motives more often, with younger siblings in particular better able to solve conflicts.58 The study looked only at short-term effects. Kennedy and Kramer (2008) taught 4- to 8-year-old siblings emotional and social skills, and afterwards they got along better and handled their emotions better than children on a wait list.109 For more, see siblings in the best-proven approach.
Things you can say
I’m not going to decide who’s right. I’m going to help you both work it out.
You both want the same toy. That’s a tough problem. What ideas do you have?
Tell me what happened. Then it’s your sister’s turn, and nobody interrupts.
In our family we don’t hurt each other. You can be angry and still keep your hands to yourself.
You worked that out yourselves. That was hard, and you did it.
Preventing the next one
Give each child some one-on-one connection time, even 10 minutes a day.
Notice them getting along: “You two built that together.” Praise is one of the few techniques that meta-analyses of parenting program trials have linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior.16
Agree on a few family rules together at a family meeting, such as no hurting and ask before you take.
Plan for the usual flashpoints: a timer for turns, a shelf for special things that don’t have to be shared, separate seats in the car.
On calm days, practice the skills: naming feelings, asking for a turn, trading, walking away.
Avoid comparing your children, even to encourage them.
When to get help
One child is regularly hurt, frightened or picked on, or the aggression mostly goes one way.
Fights often cause injuries or involve objects used as weapons.
A child seems anxious, sad or withdrawn, or starts dreading time at home. Sibling aggression in the past year was linked with more mental health distress in children and teens in a national sample.139
Offer two small choices: “Dinosaur pajamas or striped ones? Hop to bed or tiptoe?”
Use when-then: “When your teeth are brushed, then we’ll read.”
If they need reassurance, promise to come back and check on them soon, and keep the promise.
If your child gets out of bed, walk them back calmly with as few words as possible, every time. No new conversation, no extra story.
Why it happens
Bedtime asks a lot of a child: stop playing, say goodnight to you and lie still in the dark, usually at the end of a long day for everyone. Stalling for one more drink or one more hug makes sense from their side.
The good news is that bedtime problems usually respond to behavioral approaches. Mindell et al. (2006) reviewed 52 treatment studies and concluded that these approaches work for bedtime problems and night waking in infants and young children: 94% of the studies reported them effective, and more than 80% of treated children showed clinically significant improvement that lasted 3 to 6 months.158 Even a steady routine on its own helps. When Mindell et al. (2009) took 405 mothers and their infants or toddlers through a 3-week randomized study, a consistent nightly routine shortened the time children took to fall asleep, cut the number and length of night wakings and improved mothers’ mood.159
Sleep and daytime behavior go together: in its 2016 consensus statement, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine links regularly sleeping the recommended hours with better attention, behavior, learning and emotional regulation.161 For the hours to aim for, see the prevention list below; for how sleep fits with learning, see sleep and screens in Encouraging learning.
Things you can say
Bath, pajamas, teeth, two books, a song, lights out. Just like every night.
Dinosaur pajamas or the striped ones? You choose.
It’s sleep time now. I’ll come back to check on you soon.
Back to bed. I love you. See you in the morning.
You stayed in your bed all night. You can be proud of that.
Preventing the next one
Same steps, same order, every night. When Mindell et al. (2009) randomized families to a consistent nightly routine, infants’ and toddlers’ sleep improved.159
Put the steps on a picture chart, so the chart is the boss instead of you. Try the routine chart.
Keep bedtime and wake-up time steady and plan for enough sleep. In its 2016 consensus statement, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommends, per 24 hours, 11-14 hours at ages 1-2 and 10-13 hours at ages 3-5 (naps included), and 9-12 hours at ages 6-12.161
Turn screens off well before bed. The American Academy of Pediatrics, in its 2016 statement on young children and media, recommended no screens in the hour before bedtime,148 and of the 67 studies of school-age children and teens that Hale and Guan (2015) systematically reviewed, 90% linked screen time with worse sleep, mainly shorter or later, though cause and effect was not confirmed.155
Fit some connection time into the evening, so bedtime isn’t the only time your child gets you to themselves.
Praise staying in bed the next morning, warmly and specifically.
When to get help
Bedtime is still a nightly battle after a few weeks of a steady routine. Ask your pediatrician about behavioral sleep help: Mindell et al. (2006), reviewing 52 studies, concluded that behavioral treatments work for bedtime problems and night waking in young children.158
Your child snores loudly, gasps or seems to stop breathing during sleep.
Your child regularly sleeps much less than recommended for their age and seems tired, irritable or unfocused during the day.
Fears, nightmares or night waking are getting worse, or worries at bedtime come with anxiety during the day as well.
Pushing children to eat can backfire,154 so keep the jobs clear: you decide what is served and when, your child decides whether and how much to eat, and you discipline behavior at the table, not appetite.
Take a breath and drop the battle over bites: no pleading, bribing, threats, following them around with a spoon or counting spoonfuls.
If your child won’t eat, say calmly that it’s fine and that the next food comes at the next meal or snack. Then stick to it, without cooking something else.
Keep the talk off the food. Chat about the day, not about what’s left on the plate.
Let comments like “yuck” pass without a reaction (planned ignoring), and notice good table manners out loud.
For toddlers, keep sitting time short and end the meal when they’re clearly done.
Why it happens
A child who refuses dinner may simply not be hungry. The food may be unfamiliar, and the child wary of it. Some children have also discovered that the table is a fine place to have a say. Whatever the reason, pressure can make it worse. Galloway et al. (2006) tested this in an experiment with preschoolers: the children ate significantly more, and made far fewer negative comments about the food, when they were not pressured than when they were asked to finish it.154
What does help is tasting, again and again, without pressure. Wardle et al. (2003) ran a small randomized trial in 3 elementary schools with 49 children: those offered a taste of sweet red pepper in 8 daily sessions over 2 weeks, and told they could eat as much as they liked, came to like it more and ate more of it than children who had no treatment.163 A sticker reward for eating at least one piece gave in-between results that did not differ significantly from tasting or from no treatment.163
That leaves the discipline side of mealtimes narrow: steady routines, calm limits on behavior at the table, and no battles over bites. What to cook, and how to make family meals something everyone enjoys, is the territory of our sister site Show Tell Share.
Things you can say
You don’t have to eat it. It can just sit on your plate.
Is your tummy full, or would you like some more?
Food stays on the table. If it gets thrown, dinner is over.
Dinner’s finished. Next food is snack time after your bath.
Thanks for sitting with us. I like eating together.
Preventing the next one
Keep regular meal and snack times, so your child comes to the table hungry rather than full from grazing.
Serve new foods again and again, with no pressure, next to something your child already likes. Wardle et al. (2003) found, in a small school trial, that repeated tasting raised children’s liking for a new vegetable and how much they ate.163
You don’t need prizes for eating. In the same trial, a sticker reward for eating did not clearly help.163
Eat together when you can, with screens off. In its 2016 statement on young children and media, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended screen-free mealtimes.148
Let your child help: washing vegetables, setting the table, choosing between two vegetables for dinner (offering choices). For ideas on food and family meals, visit our sister site Show Tell Share.
How to end screen time with less fighting: warn ahead, stop at a natural break, hold the limit calmly, and agree on a family plan for when screens are used.
Give a warning a few minutes before the end, then stop at a natural break, such as the end of an episode or a level.
Go to your child and get their attention before you speak. Then say it once, clearly: time to turn it off. See clear expectations and instructions.
Offer a small choice about how it ends: your child presses the off button, or you do.
If your child refuses, turn it off yourself, calmly and without a lecture. This is follow-through, not a punishment.
Name the feeling and keep the limit: your child can be upset, and the screen stays off. Don’t hand it back to stop the crying.
Move straight on to the next thing: a snack, a walk, a job you do together.
Why it happens
Screens are built to hold attention. Most digital platforms, the American Academy of Pediatrics notes in its 2026 policy statement, are designed to boost engagement and profit rather than to support children’s health and development.160 Adults struggle to stop something designed to be hard to stop. Expect protests at switch-off time, and plan for them.
Limits are worth holding. Madigan et al. (2019) followed 2,441 Canadian children and found more screen time at age 2 linked with lower scores on a developmental screening test at age 3, and more screen time at age 3 with lower scores at age 5, all based on mothers’ reports.115 Sleep is the other worry. Hale and Guan (2015) reviewed 67 studies of school-age children and teenagers; 90% linked screen time with worse sleep, mostly shorter or later sleep, though the review could not confirm that screens were the cause.155
This guide is about limits and switching off. For how screens fit with sleep and learning, see sleep and screens in Encouraging learning.
At 10 to 12. Social media and group chats enter the picture. The American Academy of Pediatrics’ 2016 statement for ages 5 to 18 asks for a family media plan with consistent rules, boundaries on content and on sharing personal information, and open conversation about what happens online, and says no single rule fits every child.152 Make the plan with your preteen (solving problems together). Keep devices out of the bedroom at night, since later bedtimes and shorter sleep are the most consistent findings on media and sleep.150 And keep the fear in proportion: Orben and Przybylski (2019) analyzed three large datasets covering more than 355,000 teenagers and found only a small link between technology use and well-being.122 See screens on the Preteens page, and sleep, screens and social media on the Preteens learning page.
Things you can say
2 more minutes. When the timer rings, the tablet goes to sleep.
This is the last episode. Do you want to turn it off, or should I?
You really wanted to keep watching. It’s off now. Let’s go find a snack.
You turned it off as soon as the timer rang. Thank you.
Let’s make our screen plan together: when, where and for how long.
Preventing the next one
Make a family media plan at a family meeting: when, where and for how long screens are used, written down where everyone can see it. Madigan et al. (2019), who ran a large study of screen time in young children, recommend one.115
Keep meals screen-free and turn screens off 1 hour before bed, as the American Academy of Pediatrics advised in its 2016 statement on young children and media.148
Follow the same statement’s age guide for children aged 0 to 5: before 18 months, no screens except video chat; at 18 to 24 months, if you start, choose high-quality programs and watch together; at ages 2 to 5, 1 hour a day or less of high-quality programs, shared with you when you can.148
Make the end predictable with a timer or a picture schedule, and the start with a when-then: homework or bath first, then the tablet. See routines and visual schedules.
When screen time is over, put devices out of sight, and keep them out of bedrooms at night.
Let the plan cover adults too: phones away at meals and during play.
When to get help
Screens are crowding out sleep, school, friends or active play, and a clear plan hasn’t helped after several weeks. See when it is not working.
Your child has intense outbursts or becomes aggressive nearly every time a screen goes off.
You are worried about your child’s talking, play or social development. Ask your pediatrician about a developmental assessment.
Your child seems frightened, upset or secretive about something seen or someone met online.
Sleep problems continue even with screens off for the hour before bed.
Take a breath before you respond, so the conversation starts calm.
If you already know what happened, don’t ask a test question like “Did you do this?” Say what you saw: “I see crayon on the wall.”
Tell your child you’d be glad to hear the truth. Talwar et al. (2015) tested this with 372 children aged 4 to 8, and more of them told the truth when the adult had said they would be happy to hear it.135
When your child does tell the truth, thank them first. Then deal with what happened.
If the story is really a wish (“A monster did it”), answer the wish: “You wish it hadn’t happened.” Then fix it together.
Why it happens
Lying is common in young children. In lab studies, children were asked not to peek at a toy while the adult wasn’t looking, and most peeked. Evans and Lee (2013) ran this with 2- and 3-year-olds: most 2-year-olds who peeked admitted it, but older children were more likely to deny it.99 With children aged 3 to 8, Talwar and Lee (2008) found that most who peeked later lied about it, although what they said next sometimes gave the truth away.133
Early lies go along with growing thinking skills. In the 3- to 8-year-olds, a first denial went with understanding what someone else believes and with self-control, and keeping a lie going went with more advanced reasoning about what others think.133 In the 2- and 3-year-olds, executive function skills (such as self-control) predicted which children lied, even after taking age into account.99 So a young child’s lie is a chance to teach honesty, not proof that something is wrong.
How adults respond matters. Talwar and Lee (2011) compared two West African schools in a natural experiment: more 3- and 4-year-olds lied about peeking at the school that relied on punishment than at the one that did not, and they were better at keeping the lie going.134 In another experiment, this one with children aged 4 to 8, Talwar et al. (2015) found that children who were told they would feel good about themselves for telling the truth were less likely to lie when they did not expect punishment than when they did.135 Both studies point the same way: make the truth safe to tell.
At 10 to 12. Lies get more sophisticated: when Evans and Lee (2011) tested 8- to 16-year-olds, how well children covered a lie, but not whether they lied, went with their executive functioning skills.98 Catching every lie stops being possible. Making the truth safe to tell, and separating the consequence for the deed from the consequence for the lie, matters more. See honesty and trust on the Preteens page.
Things you can say
I’ll be really glad if you tell me what happened.
Thank you for telling me the truth. That took courage. Now let’s fix it together.
I see juice on the floor. Let’s get a cloth.
You wish the cup hadn’t broken. Me too. What can we do now?
When you tell me the truth, it’s easier for me to trust you with more.
Preventing the next one
Make the truth safe to tell: stay as calm as you can when you hear bad news, and keep consequences small and linked to what happened.
Let your child know that honesty matters to you, and that you want to hear the truth even when it’s hard to hear.
Don’t ask questions you already know the answer to.
Notice honest moments out loud: “You told me even though you knew I might be upset. Thank you.” See specific praise and attention.
Be honest with your child yourself, in small things too: if you’re not buying a toy, say no rather than “The store is closed.”
Spend a little one-on-one time together each day, so your child has easy chances to tell you things. See connection time.
When to get help
Lying is frequent and comes with other serious problems, such as stealing, hurting others or trouble at school.
Your child seems to lie out of fear, or you suspect they are covering for someone who is hurting them. See help lines.
Get close, get their attention, say one short instruction, wait a few seconds, then guide them through it and thank them. Being ignored by a toddler is a stage, not a verdict.
Go to your child, get down to their level and get their attention first: say their name, touch their arm, wait for them to look. The order matters. Schaffer and Crook (1980) found that with 15- and 24-month-olds a mother’s instruction was most likely to succeed as part of a sequence, first drawing the child’s attention to the object, then asking for the action.57
Give one short instruction as a statement, not a question, and show it with a gesture: “Cup on the table,” with a tap on the table. See clear expectations and instructions.
Then wait a few seconds, quietly. Toddlers need a moment to switch from what they are doing. Don’t repeat yourself yet, and don’t add more words.
If nothing happens, say it once more with a when-then or a two-way choice: “When the cup is on the table, then we go outside,” or “Do you want to carry the cup, or shall I?” See when-then and offering choices.
Still nothing? Guide them through it, hands on and calm: put your hand over theirs and move the cup together, or take their hand and walk to the bathroom together. Wilder and Atwell (2006) tried this with six typically developing preschoolers: an instruction followed by progressively firmer prompts, ending in gentle physical guidance, reduced noncompliance for four of them.61
Thank them the moment it is done, even if you helped: “Thank you, cup on the table!” Then let it go: no lecture, no sigh, no grudge.
If what they are ignoring is a “stop” rather than a “do”, move them or the object instead of repeating yourself, and offer what they can do: “Crayons are for paper. Here is the paper.” See redirection. If they keep going back to it, see my toddler keeps testing limits.
Why it happens
You say your toddler’s name and nothing happens. You ask again, louder, and they carry on stacking cups as if you were not in the room. Before you decide that your child is willful or that you have lost your authority, know two things. This is what toddlers do. And the steps above change it more than volume does.
Why toddlers tune you out. Two things are growing at once. The first is autonomy: a 2-year-old is discovering that they are a separate person with plans of their own, and carrying on with those plans is the simplest way to say so. Crockenberg and Litman (1990) studied 95 two-year-olds and treated this growing autonomy as a competence, measured through three kinds of behavior at once, defying, complying and asserting themselves, which is a useful reminder that doing it their own way is part of becoming a separate person, not only a problem to fix.93 The second is self-control, which is still under construction: when Vaughn et al. (1984) assessed 72 children aged 18 to 30 months, the ability to wait for something attractive and the ability to follow a mother’s directions to tidy up both increased with age, and the authors conclude that self-control emerges and settles during the second and third years of life.142 What you are asking for matters too. Kochanska et al. (2001) followed 108 children from 14 to 45 months, and “do” requests, such as keeping at a tedious task like tidying up, were much harder for children at every age than “don’t” requests, such as leaving something attractive alone.112 “Come here” and “put it away” are exactly the instructions a toddler is least equipped to follow.
Ignoring is a stage. When Kuczynski et al. (1987) watched 1½- to 3½-year-olds at home, passive noncompliance, the quiet carrying-on that parents experience as being ignored, decreased with age, as did outright defiance, while negotiating increased; children whose mothers reasoned and made suggestions tended to negotiate, and more direct maternal strategies went with defiance.44 Your toddler is not becoming more defiant. They are on their way to becoming a child who argues back, which, oddly enough, is progress.
Why the steps work. Getting close and getting attention comes first because a toddler handles one thing at a time, which is what Schaffer and Crook (1980) saw in their 15- and 24-month-olds: instructions worked best as part of an attention-then-action sequence.57 Radley and Dart (2016) reviewed 42 studies and concluded that delivering an instruction effectively, and starting with a few easy requests before a harder one, may be considered evidence-based ways to increase cooperation.54 In the programs that teach it, an effective instruction is given up close, once you have your child’s attention, as a short statement followed by a short wait; the parents Mandal et al. (2000) trained in it raised cooperation in children who had been following fewer than half of first-time instructions,49 and with 5- and 6-year-olds, Ford et al. (2001) found that it alone raised instruction-following by 21% to 44% above baseline.37
Why hands-on, calm and brief. Guiding your child’s hands through the task when they do not respond is the toddler version of follow-through, and it keeps the moment short and calm. Its evidence is mixed: Wilder and Atwell (2006) saw it work for four of six preschoolers,61 and Wilder et al. (2010) for one of six young children, where what worked for the rest was getting something they wanted once they had complied, which is when-then.62 The same six children also heard reasons, before or after the instruction, and that helped none of them, so save the reasons for a calm moment later.62 The calm, teaching tone matters in the long run: Houck and LeCuyer-Maus (2004) observed mothers setting limits when their children were 12, 24 and 36 months old, and a teaching-based pattern gave the most consistently positive results, while a power-based pattern went with poorer self-control at age 5.104 With a 1-year-old, the gentle route also beats punishment: when Power and Chapieski (1986) watched 18 toddlers aged 12 to 15 months at home, the children of mothers who relied on physical punishment were more likely to ignore their mothers’ prohibitions.77
Why thanks and choices. Thanking your child right away keeps your attention flowing to the behavior you want. Praise on its own has mixed results for compliance,52 but in parenting program trials it was among the few techniques linked with stronger effects,16 and the aim is wider than obedience anyway: among the 108 children Kochanska et al. (2001) followed to 45 months, those who went along wholeheartedly rather than only under pressure were the ones who later kept the rules when alone.112 Choices get things moving because they give the growing autonomy a say: Patall et al. (2008) pooled 41 studies, and having a choice raised motivation, more so in children than in adults.53
At 3 to 5. The same steps work, with a few more words allowed: two-step instructions, three choices, and a reason once the thing is done rather than before. A short time-out becomes an option for outright refusals: Leijten et al. (2018) pooled the experimental studies, and time-out for not following an instruction reliably increased cooperation.45 When your preschooler’s silence turns into “no”, the defiance guide takes over from here.
Things you can say
Look at me. Cup on the table.
When the blocks are in the box, then we read the book.
Walk to the bath, or shall I carry you?
I’m going to help your hands. Here we go, together.
Thank you! Shoes on, all by yourself.
Preventing the next one
Give fewer instructions, and make each one count: one at a time, up close, said once. A toddler who hears a stream of “come here” from across the room learns that most of them don’t mean anything. See follow-through.
Fill the day with attention for what you want to see: a smile, a word, a “thank you” when they come the first time. Across the two meta-analyses of parenting program trials by Leijten et al. (2019), praise and other positive reinforcement were among the few techniques linked with stronger effects on difficult behavior.16 See specific praise and attention.
Spend a few minutes a day following your child’s lead, with no instructions at all. When Kaminski et al. (2008) pooled 77 evaluations of parenting programs, the ones that taught positive parent-child interaction had larger effects.11 See connection time.
Move in before trouble builds: steer them toward what they can do instead of calling across the room to stop. See redirection.
Let the small stuff go. Whining, dawdling and silly noises get nothing from you; coming when called gets your full attention. See planned ignoring.
Keep the big transitions the same every day, with a warning before each one: “Two more slides, then shoes.” See routines and visual schedules.
When to get help
Your child ignores you most of the time, in every setting, and it is not getting better after several weeks of steady effort with the steps above. See when it is not working.
When a toddler keeps going back to the same off-limits thing, make it hard to reach, stop each attempt with your body rather than your voice, and give the same short consequence every time, from every adult who looks after them. The testing fades as self-control grows.102
Move first, talk second. Step in and block the reach, lift your child away, or put your body between your child and the pet. Calm hands, low voice, no chasing. See how to step in physically, calmly.
Say one short rule, in the same words every time, and then stop talking: “Gentle with the dog,” or “Cups stay on the table.” No lecture and no second warning.
Give the same short consequence straight away: a minute or two in a safe spot beside you that your child can’t leave, such as a playpen or a corner behind a safety gate, where you can see each other. From about 3, this becomes a short time-out. If your child climbs out, lift them back without a word and start the minute again. Never lock a door, never hold your child down and never hit.
While the break runs, close the temptation for this session: the plant goes up high, the pet goes behind its gate. There is no second try today at that spot.
If your child heads straight back once the break is over, act at the first step toward it, with no warning: straight back to the break, and that activity is finished for the rest of the day. Every adult in the house does the same.
When a break ends, start fresh. Help your child put right what they can, show the gentle way with your hand over theirs, and say thank you for the first gentle moment you see. See repair after conflict.
Why it happens
You move the plant, and your child goes back for the leaves. You say no, and they hold your eye and do it anyway. It looks like defiance. It works better to treat it as a question your child keeps asking: does this limit hold every time, or only sometimes? Everything above is built to make the answer the same, every time, from everyone.
Why toddlers keep testing. Saying no is so ordinary at this age that Wierson and Forehand (1994) call it a normal characteristic of the developing 2- to 3-year-old.29 Self-control is still being built: when Vaughn et al. (1984) assessed 72 children between 18 and 30 months, the ability to wait for something attractive and the ability to follow a mother’s directions both grew with age.142 Rules start small, too. In the families Gralinski and Kopp (1993) followed, mothers’ earliest rules centered on safety, children kept best to the rules about safety and other people’s things, and the shift from being held to a rule to holding it themselves came gradually.102 A toddler who keeps going back is somewhere in the middle of that shift.
Prevention does half the work. Every tempting thing within reach is a no you will have to enforce many times over, so take away the ones you can. Holden (1983) watched 24 mothers shopping with their toddlers, and while all of them sometimes reacted after the fact, the mothers who often headed off trouble in advance, by turning the child’s attention elsewhere, had children with fewer undesired behaviors.103 Families can make these changes stick: in the Cochrane review by Kendrick et al. (2012), home safety programs got more families storing medicines and cleaning products out of reach, though the evidence that they cut injuries was weaker.108 A gate still needs a grown-up nearby. Mothers in the diary study by Morrongiello et al. (2006) recorded how they supervised their 2- to 5-year-olds, and alongside the child’s temperament, supervision helped predict the injuries that needed medical care.117
Hands first, then one short line. A “no” called across the room leaves the next move to your child. Walking over and blocking the reach, or lifting your child away, takes it out of their hands in seconds, and it is a safety action, not a punishment (see how to step in physically, calmly). Keep it calm. Houck and LeCuyer-Maus (2004) observed mothers setting limits when their children were 12, 24 and 36 months old: a teaching-based pattern gave the most consistently positive results at 36 months, while a power-based pattern went with poorer self-control at 5.104 Then say the rule once, in the same few words. A short reprimand is not harsh, and across the studies of children aged 1.5 to 11 that Owen et al. (2012) reviewed, reprimands consistently increased compliance.52 Long explanations add little at this age: Wilder et al. (2010) gave six young children reasons before or after an instruction, and the reasons helped none of them.62 If your child ignores “stop” in general, not only around one tempting thing, see my toddler ignores me.
The same short consequence, enforced. A brief break from the action is one of the best-tested consequences there is. Leijten et al. (2018) pooled 19 experiments and found that time-out for not cooperating robustly increased children’s compliance, though most children in those studies were between 3 and 8.45 Hence a short break beside you for a younger toddler, and a proper time-out from about 3. The details decide whether it works. When Riley et al. (2017) surveyed 401 parents at check-ups, about three in four used time-out, and most of them did it in ways the evidence does not support.56 Drayton et al. (2014) went through 102 web pages on time-out, found none that got every part right, and note that dropping any single part makes it less effective.35 Staying in the break is one of those parts. In a study of 24 preschoolers, Bean and Roberts (1981) found that compliance rose under both versions of time-out they tested, but when children could leave whenever they chose, the gain was judged too small to matter; in the other version, a spanking was used to prevent early escapes.30 Day and Roberts (1983) then compared that spanking with a barrier as the response when 16 noncompliant preschoolers left time-out, found the two equally effective, and concluded that enforcing a minimum time-out was the critical part.32 At home, a playpen or a safety gate across a doorway does the barrier’s job, with you in sight and silent.
When your child runs straight back. This is the moment that decides whether the testing stops. A limit that holds only some of the time is still worth testing, and it only takes one adult laughing it off, or a consequence that arrives on the fourth try. Gardner (1989) watched families at home and found that mothers of preschoolers with conduct problems failed to follow through on their demands in more of their conflicts than other mothers did, and the less consistent the mother, the more conflict there was in the family.38 So a quick return gets a quicker answer: no warning, straight to the break, and the activity is over for the day. Closing it like that is a logical consequence, one of only three techniques Leijten et al. (2019) found linked with stronger effects in parenting program trials.16 It works only if every adult does it. Teubert and Pinquart (2010) pooled 59 studies and found that how well parents cooperate and agree is linked with how children are doing, small effects that held after each parent’s own parenting was taken into account.136
Pets need a plan of their own. A pet can answer back, so this part has no exceptions. Most of the research is on dogs. Schalamon et al. (2006) reviewed ten years of dog bites to children in one district and found the yearly rate highest at age 1, with 82% of the dogs familiar to the child; half of the injuries were to the face, head or neck.129 Among 100 children treated in emergency departments, Kahn et al. (2003) found that those bitten at home had a median age of 5 and no adult supervising them at the time.107 A calm dog is no guarantee either. When Reisner et al. (2007) studied dogs brought to a veterinary behavior clinic after biting a child, two thirds of those with a known history had never bitten a child before, and children under 6 were most often bitten while the dog was guarding food or other things it valued.127 Even friendly contact counts: Arhant et al. (2017) point out that at these ages petting, as well as interfering with the dog’s things, commonly comes before a bite from the family dog, and they call for prevention aimed at parents from the very start.87 So keep the pet’s food and bed off-limits and give it a retreat your child cannot enter. When play turns rough, your body goes between them before anything else.
Repair, and practice for the gentle version. After the break, let your child help put things right, wiping up the spill or gathering the soil, with you alongside. Toddlers manage more of this than you might expect. Drummond et al. (2017) led 32 toddlers, about two and a half on average, to believe they had broken an adult’s toy: some owned up and tried to fix it, others kept away from the adult, and the ones who tried to fix it later helped an adult in distress faster and more often.96 The motive changes around the third birthday. Vaish et al. (2016) found that 2-year-olds repaired harm whoever had caused it, out of sympathy, while 3-year-olds repaired most when they had caused it themselves.141 Keep repair practical and warm, never a shaming. With a pet, practice the gentle version with your hand over your child’s, a few strokes at a time. In the studies Shen et al. (2017) pooled on teaching children how to behave with dogs, instruction with a live dog did the most for behavior, though the quality of the evidence was poor.130 Then notice the gentle moments out loud. Praise and other positive reinforcement were among the three techniques linked with stronger effects in the trials Leijten et al. (2019) pooled.16
What about spanking? Some parents wonder whether a smack would make the stop stick. Most of the research points the other way, and part of it concerns this exact behavior: when Power and Chapieski (1986) observed 18 toddlers at home, those whose mothers relied on physical punishment were more likely to ignore their mothers’ prohibitions and to handle breakable objects.77 Gershoff and Grogan-Kaylor (2016) pooled 111 effect sizes from 160,927 children, and 13 of 17 mean effects linked spanking with a higher risk of detrimental outcomes,67 and in its 2018 policy statement the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that adults not hit children at all.78 A minority of researchers, Larzelere et al. (2024) among them, point to large effects in clinic programs for defiant young children that used spanking to enforce time-out.74 In the direct comparison by Day and Roberts (1983), though, a barrier worked as well as spanking did.32Physical discipline sets out both sides, and looks at studies from China on whether children who were hit grow up more disciplined. For this problem, the stronger tools are the ones on this page: your body between your child and the thing, and a break that is enforced every time.
How long it takes. When a behavior stops working, it can flare up before it fades. Lerman and Iwata (1995) went through 113 sets of data from applied behavior research and found such a burst in about a quarter of cases: 12% when withholding the payoff was combined with other procedures, 36% when it was used alone.47 That is one more reason to pair every stop with a gentle alternative and plenty of praise. Over the months, development does much of the rest. Kochanska et al. (2001) followed 108 children from 14 to 45 months: at every age, leaving something attractive alone came more easily than a tedious “do”, and the children who went along wholeheartedly were the ones who kept the rules when no one was watching.112 Measure progress by fewer returns in a session, then fewer sessions that end early, not by a toddler who never tests again.
At 3 to 5. From about 3, the break becomes a short time-out, and a reason can follow once everyone is calm. If the testing turns into flat refusals, defiance and “no” takes over from here, and if it turns into hitting or biting, see hitting and biting.
Things you can say
Gentle hands. I’m moving you.
You went back to the plant, so it’s a break.
That’s finished for today. We’ll try again tomorrow.
Let’s wipe it up together.
You stroked her so softly. She likes that.
Preventing the next one
Make the off-limits things hard to reach before you have to forbid them: plants and drinks up high, and a safety gate across any room you can’t watch. Holden (1983) watched mothers shopping with their toddlers, and the ones who often steered their child’s attention before trouble started had children with fewer undesired behaviors.103
Give a pet a retreat your child can’t follow it into, such as a gated room or a crate, and keep its food and bed there. Pet time happens only with an adult right beside them, and ends before either of them has had enough.
Stay close rather than relying on the rule. Morrongiello et al. (2001) found that what 4- to 6-year-olds knew about their parents’ safety rules did not predict their injuries, while how well they kept the rules and how closely they were supervised did.118
Give the urge somewhere to go, like a basket your child is allowed to tip out and pull apart. See redirection.
Agree on the plan with everyone who looks after your child: the same rule line, the same break, the same end-of-day rule. See when caregivers disagree.
Spend a few minutes a day on play your child leads, with nothing to correct. In the 77 evaluations of parenting programs Kaminski et al. (2008) analyzed, the programs that taught positive parent-child interaction had larger effects.11 See connection time.
When to get help
The plan has run the same way, with every adult who looks after your child, for several weeks, and the returns are not getting any fewer. See when it is not working.
Get close, get your child’s attention, and give one short instruction as a statement, not a question: “Shoes on, please,” not “Can you put your shoes on?” See clear expectations and instructions.
Then wait quietly for a few seconds. Don’t repeat it or add more words yet.
If your child starts to do it, say thank you right away.
If not, say it once more and add a small choice or a when-then: “Red shoes or blue?” or “Shoes first, then you can bring your dinosaur.”
Still no? Follow through calmly with a small consequence, without arguing: a short time-out from about age 3, or losing a small privilege for older children. In the experiments Leijten et al. (2018) pooled, time-out for not following an instruction reliably increased cooperation.45
With a toddler, guide them through it instead: take their hand and walk together, or put the shoes on together, then thank them. If your toddler simply carries on as if you had not spoken, my toddler ignores me has the steps for that, and if they keep going back to something you have stopped, see my toddler keeps testing limits.
When it’s over, it’s over: no lecture and no grudge. Reconnect warmly. If you lost your temper, see repair after conflict.
Why it happens
Refusals wear parents down, but you have more influence than it feels like in the moment. Research points to what you can change: how you give the instruction, and what happens after it.
How you ask: having reviewed 42 studies, Radley and Dart (2016) concluded that delivering instructions effectively, and starting with a few easy requests your child is likely to follow before a harder one, may be considered evidence-based ways to increase cooperation.54 What happens next: across the experiments Leijten et al. (2018) pooled, time-out and briefly ignoring the child after a refusal both reliably increased cooperation.45 Praise on its own had mixed results for getting children to follow an instruction,52 but it still earns its place: in the 2 meta-analyses of parenting program trials by Leijten et al. (2019), praise and other positive reinforcement, along with natural and logical consequences, were the techniques linked with stronger program effects on difficult behavior.16
For children 7 and older whose defiance is persistent, solving problems together is another option with trial evidence. Ollendick et al. (2015) randomized 134 children aged 7 to 14 with a diagnosis of oppositional defiant disorder, and Collaborative and Proactive Solutions, an approach in which adult and child work out solutions together, worked as well as parent management training: after either treatment, about half the children no longer met the diagnosis and were much improved, compared with none on the waiting list.51
At 10 to 12. Flat refusals turn into negotiation. Across the studies Laursen et al. (1998) pooled, arguments get less frequent but more heated from early to mid-adolescence, though the finding on heat rests on few studies,113 and in the families Fuligni and Eccles (1993) followed, children who saw no growing say in family decisions turned more sharply toward peers.100 Give a real say in the rules, keep the ones that matter, and take the argument to the family meeting instead of the doorway. See handing over decisions on the Preteens page.
Things you can say
Coat on now, please.
Do you want to hop to the bath like a frog, or stomp like a dinosaur?
First the blocks go in the box, then we read a story.
You don’t want to stop playing. I get it. It’s still time to go.
You put your shoes on the first time I asked. That got us out the door on time.
Preventing the next one
Give fewer instructions, and make each one count: one at a time, said once. Keep consequences small and the same every time, so you can follow through without anger. See follow-through.
Spend a few minutes a day doing what your child chooses, with no instructions or corrections. In the meta-analysis by Kaminski et al. (2008), parenting programs that taught positive parent-child interaction had larger effects.11 See connection time.
Catch your child cooperating and say so: in the parenting program trials Leijten et al. (2019) pooled, praise was among the few techniques linked with stronger effects on difficult behavior.16
Decide ahead of time which rules are firm and where your child can have a say, and offer choices there. See offering choices.
When to get help
Defiance happens most days, is getting worse, or is causing trouble at preschool, at school or with friends after several weeks of steady effort. See when it is not working.
Outbursts happen every day, or are very long, unpredictable or destructive. Wakschlag et al. (2012) found daily tantrums uncommon in a large sample of preschoolers (8.6%), and unpredictable, long or destructive ones were the kind they flagged as concerning.143
Defiance comes with hurting others, breaking things, or danger to your child or others.
You wonder whether attention, language or another developmental difference is part of the picture. See developmental differences.
Professional help works well for this. Comer et al. (2013) pooled 36 trials with young children: psychological treatments for disruptive behavior had large, lasting effects, and behavioral treatments had the largest.3
Check the basics first: is your child hungry, tired, unwell or overwhelmed? Meet that need before anything else.
Get down to your child’s level and ask once, calmly, for a regular voice: “I want to help. Can you ask me in your regular voice?”
When your child switches to a regular voice, answer right away, even if the answer is still no.
If the whining is about something you’ve already said no to, keep the no. Don’t give in to make it stop.
Then stop responding to the whine itself: stay calm and nearby, and turn to something else. See planned ignoring.
The moment the whining stops, turn back with warm attention.
If what your child really wants is you, say when you’ll be free, and keep that promise.
Why it happens
Think of whining as a request in a hard-to-hear voice: for something, or for you. Tired or stressed children have a harder time holding it together; Diamond (2013) notes in a review of self-control and related thinking skills that stress and lack of sleep each impair them.94 Before you treat it as a behavior problem, check the basics.
Aim your attention at the voice you want. Leijten et al. (2019) ran 2 meta-analyses of parenting program trials and found praise and other positive reinforcement among the few techniques linked with stronger program effects on disruptive behavior.16 The flip side is giving the whine itself no reaction. In the experiments Leijten et al. (2018) pooled in a separate meta-analysis, briefly ignoring a child right after they refused to cooperate reliably increased cooperation.45 Those experiments looked at refusals rather than whining, but the idea carries over: the whine gets nothing, and the regular voice gets a quick, warm answer. For more, see planned ignoring of minor misbehavior in the best-proven approach.
Things you can say
I want to hear you. Can you tell me in your regular voice?
Thanks for asking so clearly. Here you go.
I heard you. No cookies before dinner. You can pick one for after.
You want me to play with you. I’m finishing the dishes, then I’m all yours for 10 minutes.
Preventing the next one
Give attention before it’s demanded: short, warm moments through the day, plus a few minutes of connection time daily. Parenting programs that taught this kind of positive parent-child interaction had larger effects in a meta-analysis.11
Notice the regular voice and praise it. Of the techniques tested in meta-analyses of parenting program trials, praise and other positive reinforcement were among the few linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior.16
Practice at calm times, as a game: say the same thing in a whiny voice, a robot voice and a regular voice.
Turn homework from a nightly battle into a routine: same time and place, small chunks with breaks, you nearby for support, and the work left to your child.
If voices are rising, call a 5-minute break: water, a snack, a stretch.
Shrink the task: “Just the first 3 questions, then a short break.” See when-then.
Offer a choice about how, not whether: math or reading first, kitchen table or desk. See offering choices.
Sit nearby with something of your own, like a book, and let your child do the thinking. Ask “What’s the first step?” instead of giving the answer.
Keep screens off and out of sight until homework is done: homework first, then tablet.
If your child still refuses, don’t argue and don’t do it for them. Tell the teacher what’s going on, and let your child face the school’s response. See natural consequences.
Notice effort out loud: “You kept going on that hard one.”
Why it happens
Homework battles can have many sources: a tired child, a task that is too hard or too dull, a screen nearby, a parent who badly wants it done. Your job is the structure. The work itself belongs to your child.
Parents can learn to help. Patall et al. (2008) pooled 14 studies in which parents were trained to support homework, and the training led to more homework completed and fewer homework problems among elementary school children.162 How you help matters too. Barger et al. (2019) pooled 448 studies: most kinds of parent involvement in school had small positive links with how children did, but helping with homework was linked with lower achievement, though not with lower engagement or motivation.149 Hill and Tyson (2009) found the same exception for homework help in their meta-analysis of middle school students, most of them older than the children this site covers.156 These are correlations, so they can’t show that helping lowers grades. A sensible middle path is to stay available and encouraging while your child does the work.
For how homework fits with learning at this age, see first homework on the Starting school learning page or homework on the School age learning page.
At 10 to 12. Homework starts to count for more: in the US research Cooper et al. (2006) synthesized, the link with achievement was stronger from grade 7 on,151 and the middle school meta-analysis by Hill and Tyson (2009), the research nearest this age, found that involvement helped except for direct help with homework, a link rather than proof of cause.156 Hand the routine over and stay available. See homework on the Preteens learning page.
Things you can say
Homework first, then the tablet.
Math or reading first? You choose.
This one’s tricky. What’s the first step?
Let’s do 3, then take a 5-minute break.
You stuck with it even when it got hard.
Preventing the next one
Set a regular homework time and place, with screens put away. In the studies Patall et al. (2008) pooled, rule-setting by parents was more strongly linked with how children did than other kinds of homework involvement.162
After school, give your child a snack and some downtime before starting.
Use a checklist or a routine chart so the steps are clear without nagging.
Stay in touch with the teacher (and the after-school program, if homework happens there) about how long homework should take. If it routinely takes much longer, raise it early.
Help in ways that build independence: be available, ask questions, look over the finished work. See homework in Encouraging learning.
When to get help
Homework takes far longer than it should nearly every night, or your child struggles with reading, writing or math despite real effort. Ask the teacher whether an assessment would help.
Trouble focusing, finishing tasks and staying organized shows up at school and at home, not only at homework time. Talk with your pediatrician. See developmental differences.
Your child has strong worry, tears or stomachaches about school, or starts refusing to go.
Homework fights are hurting your relationship and nothing has helped after several weeks. See when it is not working.
When grandparents do things differently, stay respectful in front of your child, agree in private on the few rules that matter most, and let the small things go.
Pause before you react, and assume good intentions. Your child is watching how the adults treat each other.
If safety is involved, such as car seats, medicine, choking hazards or hitting, step in right away, kindly and firmly.
If it’s a small thing, such as an extra sweet or a later bedtime, let it go for now and talk later.
Don’t argue in front of your child, and don’t ask your child to take sides. A simple “Let’s talk about this after dinner” is enough.
If your child protests that Grandma allows it, stay calm and keep it short: different houses can have different rules.
Later, talk in private. Start with thanks, listen to their reasons, then agree together on the few rules that matter most to you.
When a grandparent sets a reasonable limit, back them up, so your child sees the adults as a team.
Why it happens
When grandparents help raise a child, they bring love, experience and a great deal of practical help. They also bring habits from another time, and their own ideas about food, sleep and discipline. Differences are to be expected, and how the adults handle them matters.
Research on coparenting, meaning how the adults raising a child work together, points the same way. Teubert and Pinquart (2010) pooled 59 studies and found that how well parents cooperated and agreed, and how much they fought or pulled the child into their disagreements, was linked with how well children were doing; the links were small, but they held up after accounting for each parent’s own parenting or the quality of the parents’ relationship, and coparenting predicted later changes in how children were doing.136
Grandparents can learn the same approach. A small randomized trial enrolled 54 grandparents caring for grandchildren aged 2 to 9, and the parenting program designed for them (Grandparent Triple P) reduced grandparent-reported behavior problems, raised grandparents’ confidence, lowered their depression, anxiety and stress, and improved their relationship with the child’s parents. Kirby and Sanders (2014) also found that the parents, who did not attend, reported fewer behavior problems, and that most effects lasted to a 6-month follow-up.13 For more, see grandparent caregivers and when caregivers disagree in the best-proven approach.
Things you can say
Mom, thank you for everything you do for the kids. Could we agree on a few things together, like bedtime?
Let’s talk about this later, just you and me.
At Grandma’s house, Grandma’s rules. At home, we do it our way.
Grandpa said no more candy today, so that’s the answer.
You did a great job raising me. I’m trying some newer ideas, and I’d love your help.
Preventing the next one
Talk early and calmly, not in the heat of the moment. Agree on a few essentials, such as safety, sleep, screens and how to respond to misbehavior, and let the rest be flexible.
Agree as a couple first. Then each of you can talk with your own parents.
Write down the daily routine and the main rules so everyone follows the same steps, ideally agreed together at a family meeting that includes the grandparents. A family rules poster can help.
Give grandparents a special role of their own, like a weekly outing or making dumplings together, and thank them often.
If grandparents help with care regularly, consider taking a parenting course together. See parenting programs.
When to get help
Disagreements are frequent or heated, often happen in front of your child, and talking hasn’t helped. A family counselor can help.
A grandparent uses harsh punishment, shaming or threats that frighten your child, or you are worried about your child’s safety. See warning signs.
Your child seems anxious or torn between the adults, or their behavior is getting worse.
You feel stuck between your partner and your parents. Counseling for the couple or the whole family can help.
The small numbers in the text point to these sources. Each one has a full entry on the Research page.
Comer, J. S., Chow, C., Chan, P. T., Cooper-Vince, C., & Wilson, L. A. S. (2013). Psychosocial treatment efficacy for disruptive behavior problems in very young children: A meta-analytic examination. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 52(1), 26-36. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaac.2012.10.001See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Drayton, A. K., Andersen, M. N., Knight, R. M., Felt, B. T., Fredericks, E. M., & Dore-Stites, D. J. (2014). Internet guidance on time out: Inaccuracies, omissions, and what to tell parents instead. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 35(4), 239-246. https://doi.org/10.1097/dbp.0000000000000059See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Ollendick, T. H., Greene, R. W., Austin, K. E., Fraire, M. G., Halldorsdottir, T., Allen, K. B., Jarrett, M. A., Lewis, K. M., Whitmore Smith, M., Cunningham, N. R., Noguchi, R. J. P., Canavera, K., & Wolff, J. C. (2015). Parent Management Training and Collaborative & Proactive Solutions: A randomized control trial for oppositional youth. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 45(5), 591-604. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2015.1004681See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Wilder, D. A., Allison, J., Nicholson, K., Abellon, O. E., & Saulnier, R. (2010). Further evaluation of antecedent interventions on compliance: The effects of rationales to increase compliance among preschoolers. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 43(4), 601-613. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2010.43-601See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Alink, L. R. A., Mesman, J., van Zeijl, J., Stolk, M. N., Juffer, F., Koot, H. M., Bakermans-Kranenburg, M. J., & van IJzendoorn, M. H. (2006). The early childhood aggression curve: Development of physical aggression in 10- to 50-month-old children. Child Development, 77(4), 954-966. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8624.2006.00912.xSee it on the Research pageBack to the text
Côté, S. M., Vaillancourt, T., LeBlanc, J. C., Nagin, D. S., & Tremblay, R. E. (2006). The development of physical aggression from toddlerhood to pre-adolescence: A nation wide longitudinal study of Canadian children. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 34(1), 71-85. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10802-005-9001-zSee it on the Research pageBack to the text
Drummond, J. D. K., Hammond, S. I., Satlof-Bedrick, E., Waugh, W. E., & Brownell, C. A. (2017). Helping the one you hurt: Toddlers’ rudimentary guilt, shame, and prosocial behavior after harming another. Child Development, 88(4), 1382-1397. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12653See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Kendrick, D., Young, B., Mason-Jones, A. J., Ilyas, N., Achana, F. A., Cooper, N. J., Hubbard, S. J., Sutton, A. J., Smith, S., Wynn, P., Mulvaney, C. A., Watson, M. C., & Coupland, C. (2012). Home safety education and provision of safety equipment for injury prevention. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2014(10). https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.cd005014.pub3See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Morrongiello, B. A., Corbett, M., McCourt, M., & Johnston, N. (2006). Understanding unintentional injury risk in young children II. The contribution of caregiver supervision, child attributes, and parent attributes. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 31(6), 540-551. https://doi.org/10.1093/jpepsy/jsj073See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Shen, J., Rouse, J., Godbole, M., Wells, H. L., Boppana, S., & Schwebel, D. C. (2017). Systematic review: Interventions to educate children about dog safety and prevent pediatric dog-bite injuries: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 42(7), 779-791. https://doi.org/10.1093/jpepsy/jsv164See it on the Research pageBack to the text
Munzer, T., Parga-Belinkie, J., Milkovich, L. M., Tomopoulos, S., Ajumobi, T., Cross, C., Gerwin, R., Madigan, S., & American Academy of Pediatrics Council on Communications and Media (2026). Digital ecosystems, children, and adolescents: Policy statement. Pediatrics, 157(2), e2025075320. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2025-075320See it on the Research pageBack to the text