Toolbox

Practical discipline tools, one card each: the steps, the ages it fits, common mistakes, words you can say, and an honest rating of the research behind it.

A parent crouches to a young child’s eye level in the kitchen doorway and speaks calmly, a school bag on the floor beside them.

Tools that work together

These tools are meant to be used together, the way the best-proven approach combines them: plenty of warm attention and praise for the behavior you want, clear instructions, calm ignoring of minor misbehavior, and brief, consistent consequences when they are needed. Kaminski et al. (2008) compared 77 evaluations of parenting programs for children aged 0 to 7 and found three things linked with larger effects: teaching positive parent-child interaction and emotional communication, teaching time-out together with consistency, and having parents practice new skills with their child during the sessions.11

Start with the positive tools at the top of the list: connection time, clear expectations and instructions, and specific praise and attention. Use them every day. Keep the consequence tools, such as time-out and privilege removal, for the times they are not enough.

How to use the cards

Each card follows the same order: the steps, then the ages the tool fits, common mistakes, words you can say, and links to related tools and situations. Use the age buttons to show only the tools for your child’s age. Practice one or two tools at a time until they feel natural, then add more. If you have used the tools consistently for several weeks and nothing is changing, see when it is not working.

The badge on each card shows how much research stands behind that tool. Emerging does not mean a tool doesn’t work, only that it has not been studied much on its own. The levels are explained just below.

Evidence

Strong
Backed by meta-analyses or several randomized trials, usually as a core part of established parenting programs.
Moderate
Backed by some controlled studies, or consistent evidence as part of parenting programs.
Emerging
Little direct research so far; the case rests on related studies or expert guidance.
Contested
Credible researchers disagree about whether it helps or harms.

Connection time

Spend a few minutes of one-on-one time with your child most days, letting them lead the play while you give your full, warm attention.

A parent and a five-year-old lie on the living-room floor drawing together with crayons on a big sheet of paper.

How to do it

  1. Pick a time you can keep up: 5-10 minutes, most days, one child at a time.
  2. Put your phone away and turn off the TV.
  3. Let your child choose what to play, and follow their lead. With younger children, blocks, crayons and pretend play are good choices; save games with strict rules or a winner for other times.
  4. Describe what your child is doing, like a friendly sports commentator: “You’re putting the red block on top.”
  5. Join in: copy their play, show that you are enjoying it, and praise the things you like.
  6. Hold back on questions, instructions, teaching and corrections. This is their time to lead.
  7. If your child does something minor you don’t like, look away for a moment and carry on when it stops. If play turns rough or destructive, calmly end it for today and try again tomorrow.

Ages it fits

Every age, in a different form. Babies: face-to-face play, copying their sounds and smiles, and responding when they reach for you. Toddlers and preschoolers: 5-10 minutes of play that they choose and lead. Once they start school: a walk, a game or a chat that they pick, with your phone put away. Preteens: an unhurried time to talk on their terms, such as a drive, a late snack or a walk, when you listen more than you ask.

Evidence strength: Moderate

When 77 evaluations of parenting programs for children aged 0 to 7 were compared, the programs that taught parents more positive interaction and emotional communication with their child had larger effects.11 With babies the same idea is called responsiveness. Landry et al. (2006) ran a randomized trial of a home-visit program that taught mothers responsive behaviors: the mothers became more responsive, and that in turn helped their infants’ social, emotional, communication and thinking skills grow.14

How much relationship time adds on top of clear limits and consequences is less clear. Leijten et al. (2018) ran two meta-analyses of randomized trials and found that programs combining relationship building with behavior management were not better overall than behavior management alone: they did better for children in treatment, worse in prevention programs, and no differently up to 3 years later.15 Connection time earns its place as one part of the best-proven approach; on its own it is not a fix.

Common mistakes

  • Turning it into a lesson: quizzing colors, correcting the drawing, or steering the game toward what you think is better.
  • Taking connection time away as a punishment. Keep it going whatever kind of day it has been.
  • Being there in body only, with one eye on your phone.
  • Giving your full attention mostly when things go wrong, and very little when they go well.
  • Expecting it to replace clear limits. Use it alongside the other tools, not instead of them.

Things you can say

It’s our special time. You choose what we play.
Wow, you’re building a really tall tower.
You gave the dinosaur a blanket. That’s so kind.
I love playing with you.
Time’s up for today. I’m looking forward to tomorrow.

Clear expectations and instructions

Tell your child exactly what to do, one step at a time and in a calm voice, and keep the house rules the same from day to day.

A parent crouches to a four-year-old’s eye level in the hallway, holding the child’s backpack straps and speaking calmly.

How to do it

  1. Get your child’s attention first: go to them, get down to eye level and say their name, rather than calling from another room.
  2. Say what to do, not what to stop: “Walk, please” instead of “Don’t run.”
  3. Make it a calm statement, not a question: “Shoes on, please” rather than “Can you put your shoes on?” Only ask if no is a fine answer.
  4. Give one instruction at a time, in a few words, then wait quietly for a few seconds (count to five in your head).
  5. If your child tends to dig in, start with one or two easy requests they enjoy (“Give me a high five!”), then give the harder one.
  6. When your child does it, notice it: “Thank you, shoes on!”
  7. If nothing happens, say it once more, firmly, then follow through the same way every time: help them do it, or use the consequence you planned, such as when-then or time-out.
  8. Keep house rules few, say them as what to do (“In our family, we speak kindly”), and agree on them with the other adults who care for your child. Write them down on our family rules poster.

Ages it fits

From toddlerhood up. Toddlers: one short instruction at a time, said up close and shown with a gesture. Preschoolers: a few simple house rules, repeated often. Once they start school: explain the reasons, and agree on some rules together, for example in family meetings. Preteens: fewer rules, agreed together and written down; say the expectation once, then let the consequence do the talking.

Evidence strength: Moderate

How you give an instruction sits at the core of the best-proven approach. Radley and Dart (2016) reviewed 42 studies of children and teenagers aged 1 to 19 and concluded that the way instructions are delivered (“effective instruction delivery”) and a run of easy requests the child is likely to follow before the harder one (“high-probability” request sequences) are among the strategies that may be considered evidence-based for helping children follow adult requests.54 Those studies ran from toddlers to teenagers, so not every finding will hold at every age. Being consistent seems to count as well: among 77 evaluations of parenting programs, the ones that taught time-out together with the importance of consistency had larger effects.11

What you do next, when your child does not comply, counts too. Owen et al. (2012) systematically reviewed 41 studies of children aged 1.5 to 11 and found that verbal reprimands and disapproving nonverbal responses consistently increased compliance, while praise had mixed effects.52 Firm is not harsh, though. The American Academy of Pediatrics (2018) says in its policy statement that yelling at or shaming children is minimally effective in the short term and not effective in the long term.78 Calm and firm, then, with no shouting and no shaming.

Common mistakes

  • Asking when you mean telling: “Shall we have a bath?” invites a no.
  • Vague instructions such as “Be good” or “Stop it” that don’t say what to do.
  • Several instructions in one breath: “Put your shoes on, get your bag and find your hat.”
  • Repeating the same instruction over and over, louder each time, and then letting it drop.
  • Rules that change with your mood, or that differ between the adults at home.
  • Shouting at or shaming your child when they don’t comply.

Things you can say

Shoes on, please. Then we can go.
Walk inside, please.
Toys go back in the box.
Gentle hands with the cat.
In our family, we speak kindly to each other.

Specific praise and attention

Notice the behavior you want to see more of and respond warmly, with words, a smile or a touch, soon after it happens.

A parent smiles with a hand on a seven-year-old’s shoulder as the child finishes making their bed.

How to do it

  1. Catch your child being good: watch for moments of the behavior you want more of, such as playing calmly, sharing or getting dressed.
  2. Respond soon, while it is happening or right after.
  3. Use your face, voice and touch as well as words: a smile, a thumbs up or a hand on the shoulder all count.
  4. Say what you liked: “You put your plate in the sink. Thank you.” Naming the behavior shows what you noticed, though a simple “Well done!” is fine too.
  5. Praise what your child did, such as effort, kindness or a good choice, rather than who they are.
  6. Aim for far more warm moments than corrections over the day.
  7. Combine it with the other tools: praise the behavior you asked for, and use planned ignoring for minor behavior you want to see less of.

Ages it fits

From toddlerhood up; for babies, warm attention is part of connection time. Toddlers and preschoolers: often, warmly and right away, with plenty of smiles and hugs. Once they start school, praise effort, kindness and good choices, and say it privately if praise in front of others embarrasses your child. Preteens: specific, private and matter-of-fact. Public praise can embarrass them, and praise for effort and strategy still beats praise for being smart.

Evidence strength: Moderate

Parenting programs teach a long list of techniques, and few of them stand out on their own. When Leijten et al. (2019) pooled randomized program trials in two meta-analyses, only 3 of the 26 techniques were linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior: positive reinforcement, praise in particular, and natural or logical consequences.16

Still, praise is one part of the whole approach, not a switch on its own. Praise did not increase children’s compliance with instructions in experiments that each tested a single parenting behavior,45 and across the 41 studies in one systematic review, its effects on compliance were mixed.52 Being specific may matter less than people say: in the two experiments Leijten et al. (2016) ran with children aged 3 to 9, praise that named the behavior worked no better than general praise.46

What you praise may matter too. Kamins and Dweck (1999) ran a small role-play experiment with 5- and 6-year-olds in which children praised as a person showed more helpless reactions after a later setback, including blaming themselves, than children praised for their effort or approach.42 Among 313 children around age 10, Brummelman et al. (2014) found that person praise made children, especially those with low self-esteem, more likely to feel ashamed after failure.166 These were short experiments. Treat this as a sensible lean, not a firm rule.

Common mistakes

  • Saving your attention for misbehavior and saying nothing when things go well.
  • Praise with a sting in the tail: “Good job cleaning up. Why can’t you do that every day?”
  • Praising your child as a person (“good girl,” “so smart”) rather than what they did.
  • Automatic or over-the-top praise that doesn’t match what actually happened.
  • Expecting praise alone to get instructions followed. On its own, praise did not raise compliance in experiments.45

Things you can say

You put your shoes on all by yourself!
Thank you for coming the first time I called.
You two are taking turns. That’s great teamwork.
You kept trying even when it was hard.
That was kind, letting your sister go first.

Planned ignoring

Deliberately withdraw your attention from minor, harmless misbehavior such as whining, and give it back warmly the moment the behavior stops.

A parent calmly washes vegetables at the sink while a three-year-old sits pouting on the kitchen floor nearby.

How to do it

  1. Decide in advance which minor behaviors you will ignore (whining, pestering, sulking, rude noises) and which you will never ignore (hitting, danger, breaking things).
  2. If it helps, say once, calmly, what you are waiting for: “When you use your normal voice, I’ll listen.”
  3. Then withdraw your attention: no eye contact, no talking, no arguing, no sighs. Turn away or busy yourself with something else.
  4. Stay close enough to keep a young child safe and to notice when the behavior stops.
  5. Be ready: the protest may get louder for a while. Decide beforehand that you will not give in.
  6. The moment the behavior stops, turn back warmly and pay attention to what your child is doing now.
  7. Pair it with plenty of specific praise and attention at other times.

Ages it fits

From toddlerhood to about 12, for small attention-seeking behavior such as whining, sulking or silly noises. Not for babies: respond to a baby’s cries. Never for anything dangerous, hurtful or destructive. Preteens: sighs, eye-rolls and muttering are the new whining; ignore the tone and respond to the words.

Evidence strength: Moderate

Planned ignoring belongs to the core of the best-proven approach, and it has been tested on its own. Leijten et al. (2018) pooled 19 experiments that each tested a single parenting behavior, and briefly ignoring a child who had not complied reliably increased compliance, although the estimates of how large the effect is ranged widely.45

What those experiments tested was short periods of ignoring right after a child refused an instruction. Ignoring whining or sulking applies the same idea; it does not rest on those tests directly. Harmless behavior only: if something is dangerous or someone could get hurt, step in right away.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring something unsafe or hurtful, such as hitting, running off or breaking things. Step in right away.
  • Giving in once the whining gets louder.
  • “Ignoring” with sighs, glares or comments, which is still attention.
  • Ignoring your child as a person, or for a long time. Planned ignoring is aimed at one behavior and lasts only as long as that behavior does.
  • Forgetting to turn back warmly when the behavior stops.
  • Ignoring real distress. A child who is scared, hurt or overwhelmed needs comfort; see time-in.

Things you can say

When you use your normal voice, I’ll listen.
Thank you for asking nicely. Let’s get your snack.
You’ve calmed down. Want to finish the puzzle together?
That’s your normal voice. Now I can help.

Redirection

Steer your child away from what they shouldn’t be doing and toward something they can do, ideally before trouble builds.

Evidence: Emerging
A parent hands a toddler a wooden spoon and a small pot while gently closing a kitchen drawer.

How to do it

  1. Move in early, at the first sign of trouble: a hand reaching for the remote, a tug-of-war starting over a toy.
  2. With a baby, simply pick them up or move the object, and offer something else interesting.
  3. From toddlerhood, name the limit in a few calm words: “Not the cord. Here’s your ball.”
  4. Offer something that meets the same need: something to bang, throw, climb or squeeze.
  5. Make the new option appealing: get down and join in for a minute.
  6. If that doesn’t work, change the scene: another room, a look out of the window, a song.
  7. Head off repeat battles by moving fragile or dangerous things out of reach.

Ages it fits

Mainly for babies and toddlers. Preschoolers can take a short reason or a choice along with the swap. Later it turns into suggesting a better way to do what they want: the ball goes outside instead of around the living room.

Evidence strength: Emerging

A baby reaching for the power cord gets moved, and handed something else; parents do this long before anyone shows them a technique. Redirection itself has barely been studied, so its case rests on expert guidance and on what toddlers are like. The American Academy of Pediatrics, in its 2018 policy statement advising against physical punishment and verbal abuse such as shaming, listed redirecting among the alternatives it recommended, alongside positive reinforcement of appropriate behavior, setting limits and setting expectations for the future.78

What toddlers are like matters here, because hitting starts early. Alink et al. (2006) found physical aggression already present at 12 months in a large sample of young children; it rose during the second year of life and declined from the third birthday onward.86 Your job at this age is to keep everyone safe and steer your child toward something better. How much of that later decline comes from redirection, and how much from simply growing older, is not known.

Common mistakes

  • Distracting without ever naming the limit. From toddlerhood, say the rule in a few words too.
  • Reaching for a screen or a snack as the distraction every time.
  • Trying to distract when there is real danger. Stop your child first; see keeping your child safe.
  • Redirecting a child who is hurt or upset instead of comforting them first. See time-in.
  • Offering a swap that doesn’t meet the need, such as a puzzle for a child who wants to climb.

Things you can say

Books are for reading. Let’s find your drum.
Gentle hands. You can squeeze this pillow.
Balls are for outside. Indoors we can roll this soft one.
The table isn’t for climbing. Want to climb the cushion mountain?
Ooh, look what’s outside the window!

Offering choices

Give your child a say by offering two options you are happy with either way, so they choose how something happens, not whether it happens.

A three-year-old chooses between two T-shirts in front of an open wardrobe, one held up by a parent.

How to do it

  1. Decide first what is not up for discussion: we are leaving, teeth get brushed, the seatbelt goes on.
  2. Offer two options you are truly fine with: “Red cup or blue cup?” “Hop or tiptoe to the bath?”
  3. Keep them small and concrete. With toddlers, hold up the actual things.
  4. Offer the choice early, before a standoff starts.
  5. If they suggest another option that is fine with you, go with it. If not, repeat the two choices once.
  6. If your child doesn’t choose within a few seconds, choose for them, calmly: “I’ll choose this time. Blue it is.”
  7. As your child gets older, hand over bigger choices with real responsibility: the order of tasks, when homework happens, how to spend pocket money.

Ages it fits

Toddlers: two options, held up or pointed to as well as said. Preschoolers: two or three options. Once they start school: bigger choices with real responsibility, such as when homework happens or which chore to take on, within limits you set. Preteens: choices with real stakes, such as how to spend pocket money or which activity to keep, plus a say in the rules themselves.

Evidence strength: Emerging

Direct research on choices as a discipline tool is scarce, so the case rests on related studies of motivation. Patall et al. (2008) pooled 41 studies with children and adults and found that being given a choice increased intrinsic motivation, effort, task performance and feelings of competence; the boost to motivation was stronger for children than for adults, stronger when no reward followed the choice, and stronger for small choices that left the task itself unchanged than for choices between activities.53

A choice is also a small act of autonomy support. Joussemet et al. (2008) draw a line between parents’ autonomy support and permissiveness, and their review finds that support consistently linked with positive outcomes across different types of studies and at different ages; in observation studies, it went with toddlers taking rules on as their own (what researchers call internalization).106 None of this work watched everyday cooperation at home. It measured motivation, tasks or associations, so choices count here as a sensible, low-cost tool rather than a proven one.

Common mistakes

  • Offering a choice you won’t accept: “Do you want to go to bed now?”
  • Too many options or an open question, such as “What do you want for breakfast?” on a rushed morning.
  • A threat dressed up as a choice: “Either you stop it or you’ll be sorry.”
  • Giving in when your child refuses both options and starts to bargain.
  • Offering choices about safety. The car seat is not optional; which song plays on the way can be.

Things you can say

Do you want the red shirt or the blue one?
Teeth first or pajamas first?
Do you want to walk to the car, or shall I carry you?
Homework before dinner or right after? You decide.
Shall we hop like bunnies or tiptoe like cats to the bath?

When-then

Link something your child wants to something that needs doing first: “When your shoes are on, then we’ll go to the park.”

A six-year-old hangs up a school bag by the door while a parent waits at the table with a plate of cut fruit.

How to do it

  1. Put the task first and the good thing second: “When the toys are in the box, then we’ll read a story.”
  2. Choose a “then” that is going to happen anyway, such as going out, a story, playtime or screen time, rather than candy or new toys.
  3. Keep the task short and clear, and the “then” soon after it. For young children, think minutes, not hours.
  4. Say it once, calmly, as a plain fact rather than a threat or a deal.
  5. Follow through both ways: when the task is done, deliver the “then” right away. If it isn’t done, the “then” waits, without a lecture.
  6. For young children, you can make a simple first-then card with two pictures.

Ages it fits

From around age 2, with short, immediate pairs: “When your hands are washed, then snack.” From preschool on it fits daily routines, screens and homework, and older children can help plan their own when-then order. Preteens: the pairs get bigger (homework done, then the group chat; room tidy by Saturday, then the sleepover), and they can set the order themselves.

Evidence strength: Emerging

Say “when your shoes are on, then the park” and you have used positive reinforcement: the wanted behavior comes first, and something your child values follows. The tool itself has little direct research, so its backing is the principle. Positive reinforcement was one of only 3 of 26 techniques that Leijten et al. (2019) found linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior in two meta-analyses of randomized parenting program trials.16

The caution is about rewards. Deci et al. (1999) and Cameron et al. (2001) are on opposite sides of the argument about how much rewards affect motivation, and both found that tangible rewards promised in advance can lower interest in a task a child already finds interesting.173169 Save when-then for tasks your child would not choose to do, and let everyday activities be the “then.”

Common mistakes

  • Turning it into a threat: “If you don’t clean up, no park!”
  • Handing over the “then” first: “Fine, watch your show, but clean up afterwards.”
  • Adding new conditions after your child has done the task.
  • Pairing it with a task your child can’t do yet, or one that takes far too long for their age.
  • Using candy or toys as the reward for things your child already enjoys doing. When children in experiments were promised a tangible reward, their later interest in activities they already liked went down.182173

Things you can say

When your shoes are on, then we’ll go to the park.
First pajamas, then story.
When your homework is done, the tablet is yours for half an hour.
As soon as the toys are away, we can go outside.

Natural consequences

When it is safe, let your child experience what naturally follows from a choice, such as feeling cold after refusing a coat, instead of rescuing or lecturing.

A seven-year-old with a school bag looks at a forgotten rain jacket by the open front door while rain falls outside.

How to do it

  1. Check three things first: is it safe, is it small, and will it happen soon enough for your child to connect it with the choice?
  2. If any answer is no, step in instead. Never let a natural consequence involve traffic, water, heat, medicines or anything that could cause lasting harm.
  3. Give one friendly heads-up, without nagging: “It’s cold out. You might want your coat.”
  4. Then let it happen and don’t rescue: for example, don’t rush the forgotten library book to school every time.
  5. Skip “I told you so.” Show sympathy instead: “Oh no, cold hands. That’s no fun.”
  6. Later, when everyone is calm, help your child think it through: “What could you do next time?”
  7. If the natural result is unsafe, too far off or would mainly hurt someone else, use logical consequences instead.

Ages it fits

Best suited to ages 5 to 12. With preschoolers, use only small, immediate ones, such as a wobbly tower falling or a game ending when a friend gets upset, and talk about what happened. Not for babies or toddlers: at that age, prevent problems and keep them safe. Preteens: forgotten gym clothes or a missed deadline teaches more than a reminder, as long as the stakes are small and safe.

Evidence strength: Moderate

The evidence here is shared with logical consequences. When Leijten et al. (2019) ran two meta-analyses of randomized parenting program trials, natural and logical consequences were among only 3 of 26 techniques linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior.16 The two were counted together, so the analysis cannot say how well natural consequences work on their own, and no technique in it, this one included, was linked with stronger effects in the longer term.16

Safe, small and soon, with sympathy in place of a lecture: the everyday rules on this card come from experience, not from trials. A natural consequence is never a reason to let a child come to harm: see dangerous behavior.

Common mistakes

  • Letting your child face real danger to “learn a lesson.”
  • Adding a lecture or an “I told you so” on top of the consequence.
  • Choosing consequences that are too far off to connect, such as a school report months away for a 6-year-old.
  • Inventing a punishment and calling it a natural consequence.
  • Letting the consequence land on someone else, such as a sibling whose toy gets broken, instead of stepping in.
  • Expecting a young child to manage alone what they still need help with. Help first with a checklist or with routines and visual schedules.

Things you can say

It’s chilly today. Coat or no coat? Your call.
Oh no, your drawing got wet. That’s disappointing.
The tower fell down. What could you try next time?
You forgot your library book, so no new book today. What would help you remember next week?

Logical consequences

A small, short consequence you set up that connects to what your child did, such as a thrown ball going on the shelf until after lunch.

A five-year-old puts toy cars back into a basket on the floor while a parent sits calmly on the sofa nearby.

How to do it

  1. Decide ahead of time which consequence goes with which behavior, and tell your child before it happens. Unlike a natural consequence, this one is set up by you.
  2. Make it connect to the behavior. Misuse a thing, lose it for a while. Make a mess, help clean it up. Go past the screen limit, lose the rest of today’s screen time.
  3. Keep it small and short, so your child gets another try soon. Choose something you will be able to carry out every time.
  4. Give one calm reminder. If it happens again, follow through in one short sentence, without a lecture.
  5. When the time is up, give the thing back or let your child try again, and notice out loud when they get it right.
  6. This is one of the brief, consistent consequences in the best-proven approach. Use it alongside plenty of praise and attention for what goes well.

Ages it fits

Toddlers need the simplest form: the consequence happens right away and is over soon, like a thrown toy going up on the shelf for a few minutes. From preschool age on, you can tell your child the consequence ahead of time and talk about it afterwards. School-age children can help you decide what is fair. Preteens: agree the consequence in advance and keep it related and short, such as the phone charging in the kitchen for the evening after it was used late at night.

Evidence strength: Moderate

Natural and logical consequences are among the few parts of parenting programs linked with stronger effects. Of the 26 techniques that such programs teach, Leijten et al. (2019) found only 3 linked with stronger effects on disruptive behavior across their 2 meta-analyses of randomized trials: positive reinforcement, praise in particular, and natural or logical consequences.16

That is a finding about programs that include the technique, not a test of logical consequences on their own, and no technique in the analysis was linked with stronger long-term effects.16 Nobody, as far as we could find, has compared one logical consequence with another or tested how long one should last. Keeping them small, related and short is practical guidance, not a tested rule.

Common mistakes

  • Making it big or long, like a week without toys. It is hard to keep up, and your child has no fresh chance to do better.
  • Inventing a consequence in anger. Plan it while you are calm.
  • Picking something unrelated, such as no dessert for not cleaning up. The link to the behavior is what makes it logical.
  • Lecturing, shaming or adding threats while you follow through. One calm sentence is enough.
  • Announcing a consequence and then not following through.
  • Using consequences for skills your child is still learning. Teach and practice those instead.

Things you can say

If the ball gets thrown in the house again, it goes on the shelf until after lunch.
The ball is going on the shelf now. You can try again after lunch.
The crayon went on the wall. Let’s get a cloth and clean it off together.
Screen time went past the timer, so screens are done for today. Tomorrow is a new try.

Time-in

You stay close to your upset child, help them calm down, and talk about what happened once they are ready.

A parent sits on the floor against the sofa holding a four-year-old on their lap, the child’s head resting on the parent’s chest.

How to do it

  1. Use it for big feelings: crying, frustration, fear, a meltdown. You can stay close and still keep the limit that set it off.
  2. Calm yourself first. Slow your breathing, lower your voice and keep your face soft.
  3. Go with your child to a calm spot, such as a cushion or a quiet corner, and stay with them.
  4. Name the feeling in a few words and offer comfort: a hug, a hand on the back, or just sitting nearby if your child doesn’t want to be touched.
  5. Wait. Don’t lecture, reason or ask why while your child is still upset.
  6. Once your child is calm, talk briefly about what happened and what they could try next time.
  7. At a calm moment, make a calm-down plan together so you both know what helps.

Ages it fits

The one study we found involved 3- to 5-year-olds.41 With a toddler, keep it very simple: stay close, use few words, offer comfort. A school-age child can tell you whether they want you right beside them or just nearby; save the talk for later.

Evidence strength: Emerging

The idea behind time-in is simple: stay with your child so they can reconnect with you, put the feeling into words and learn to calm down. Positive parenting books and articles have recommended it since at least the 1990s, yet the authors of the one study we found, Holden et al. (2022), note that few studies have tested it.41

Their study was a small pilot. Mothers of 3- to 5-year-olds had brief training and then used time-in for 2 weeks; of the 32 interviewed at the start, 19 provided mostly complete data, and those mothers rated time-in easy to use and effective.41 Encouraging, but early. The results are the mothers’ own ratings over 2 weeks, and nothing we found tracks whether time-in changes a child’s behavior over months.

You may have read that time-in should replace time-out. Dadds and Tully (2019), answering attachment-based criticism of time-out, concluded that time-out used in line with current knowledge generally enhances children’s well-being.31 The two can sit side by side: time-in for big feelings, a brief time-out for specific behaviors.

Common mistakes

  • Talking too much while your child is still upset. Use few words, then wait.
  • Giving in to the demand that started the meltdown. You can comfort your child and still keep the limit.
  • Using time-in for hitting or other behaviors you have named in advance. Time-in is for distress; for those behaviors a clear consequence such as time-out fits better.
  • Pulling a child who wants space into a hug. Sit nearby instead.
  • Expecting time-in to stop meltdowns for good. Think of it as support for this moment, not a cure.

Things you can say

You’re really upset. I’m right here.
I’m staying with you. Let’s take a big breath together.
You wanted to keep playing, and it’s time to go. That’s hard.
Do you want a hug, or should I just sit next to you?
You’re calmer now. Want to tell me what happened?

Time-out, used correctly

A short, calm break from attention for a behavior you named in advance, given after one clear warning and followed by a fresh start.

Evidence: Strong
A four-year-old sits calmly on a small stool in a quiet corner of the living room while a parent sits at the dining table in the background.

How to do it

  1. Pick one or two behaviors that lead to time-out, such as hitting, or not following an instruction after a warning. Explain them to your child at a calm time.
  2. Choose a boring, safe spot where you can see your child, such as a chair or a step away from toys and screens. Never lock a door.
  3. Give one clear warning. If the behavior happens again, say in one sentence what happened and that it’s time-out, then stop talking.
  4. Keep it short, just a few minutes. Set a timer and end it when the time is up, even if your child is still grumbling. See short time-outs.
  5. During time-out, don’t talk, argue or bargain. Stay calm and nearby.
  6. If your child gets up early, calmly bring them back and start the time again, or use the back-up you planned, such as losing a privilege later. Never hit as a back-up. More help: if your child refuses time-out.
  7. When it ends, start fresh, with no lecture. If the time-out was for not doing something, ask again and praise your child when they do it.
  8. Keep the rest of the day warm, with plenty of attention, play and specific praise. Time-out is a short break from that attention.

Ages it fits

Most of the studies here involved preschoolers, and the analysis of parenting program components by Kaminski et al. (2008) covered children aged 0 to 7.11 For a toddler, start with redirection and time-in, and for one who keeps going back to something off-limits, see my toddler keeps testing limits. For a school-age child, a short privilege removal is another option.

Evidence strength: Strong

Few discipline methods have been used as widely, or studied as much, as time-out.31 Programs that taught it, together with consistency, had larger effects across the 77 evaluations of parenting programs for children aged 0 to 7 that Kaminski et al. (2008) analyzed,11 and across 19 experimental studies pooled in one meta-analysis, time-out for not following instructions robustly increased children’s compliance.45 Does it leave a mark later? Knight et al. (2020) followed US families from early childhood to fifth grade, and children whose parents reported using time-out at age 3 did not differ significantly from other children on any emotional, behavioral or parent-child relationship outcome.43 Two reviews have weighed the criticisms. One concluded that careful use within parenting programs is justified and helps many children with conduct problems,50 and Dadds and Tully (2019), answering the worry that time-out harms attachment, concluded that time-out used in line with current knowledge generally enhances children’s well-being.31

The practical details rest on much smaller studies. Two tiny ones agree on one point: Donaldson and Vollmer (2011) worked with 4 children aged 3 and 4, a second study with 3 children, 2 of them with intellectual disabilities, and in both time-out reduced problem behavior whether it ended after a fixed time or lasted until the child had stopped misbehaving.3348 In the first of those, misbehaving during time-out did not predict misbehavior outside it.33 Among 6 preschool boys, making time-out shorter whenever a boy went straight away helped 4 of them go to time-out when asked.34 And in a clinic study of 16 noncompliant preschoolers, Day and Roberts (1983) found that a back-up for leaving time-out that did not involve spanking worked as well as spanking; they concluded that enforcing a minimum time-out length was critical in that setting.32

The best length is not known. We found no study showing that longer time-outs work better for young children at home, and when Everett et al. (2010) reviewed 30 years of research, the way time-out was carried out varied widely and often was not reported.36 Not every finding is reassuring. Gershoff et al. (2010) surveyed mothers and their 8- to 12-year-olds in 6 countries, including China, and in that cross-sectional study time-out was linked with more anxiety symptoms in children, as were corporal punishment, shaming and expressing disappointment; a study like that cannot show which came first.39

Common mistakes

  • Making it long. We found no study showing that longer time-outs work better for young children at home, and short ones are easier to carry out.
  • Giving time-out in anger, with yelling, shaming or threats. Calm and boring is the point.
  • Surprise time-outs for behaviors your child didn’t know were off-limits.
  • Ending it early because your child pleads or protests. Keep the short time you set.
  • Using a scary, dark or locked place. The spot should be boring and safe, and you should be able to see your child.
  • Using it for everything. Save it for the behaviors you named, and use planned ignoring for minor fussing.

Things you can say

Hitting hurts. If you hit again, you’ll go to time-out.
You hit, so it’s time-out. Sit here until the timer rings.
Time-out is over. Let’s try again: please put the blocks in the box.
You put them all away. Thank you, that was quick!

Privilege removal

Taking away one small, related privilege for a short, set time after a behavior you warned about, then giving your child a fresh chance.

A tablet charges in its closed cover on the kitchen counter while a school-age child reads a book at the table behind it.

How to do it

  1. Decide ahead of time which privilege goes with which behavior, and tell your child before it happens.
  2. Choose something small and related to the problem: the game the children fought over, the scooter that went into the road, the screen time that ran past the timer.
  3. Give one warning. If it happens again, remove the privilege calmly, in one sentence.
  4. Keep it short: the rest of the afternoon or evening, not a week, so your child gets a fresh chance soon. See quick privilege removal.
  5. Don’t add more when your child argues. Say it once and move on.
  6. When the time is up, give it back without a lecture, and notice when your child uses it well.
  7. Never take away meals, sleep, comfort objects or time with you.

Ages it fits

The only direct study we found involved preschoolers in a classroom.55 With preschoolers, remove something right away and give it back soon, such as the rest of this afternoon’s tablet time. With school-age children, the removal can come later the same day if you name the reason clearly. Preteens: the privilege is usually a screen, an outing or a later bedtime; keep it to an evening or a day and say exactly how it is earned back.

Evidence strength: Emerging

Direct evidence for privilege removal on its own is thin, even though it is one of the brief, calm consequences in the best-proven approach. The one direct study is small: in a classroom with 4 aggressive preschoolers, teachers took away a smiley face, with a reprimand, after each aggressive act, and a child who kept at least one face chose a reward. Reynolds and Kelley (1997) found that aggression dropped substantially and that teachers and parents rated the system highly acceptable.55 A removal tied to the behavior is a kind of logical consequence, and natural and logical consequences were among the few techniques linked with stronger results in parenting programs.16

Nobody has studied parents removing privileges at home with young children, as far as we could find, and nobody has compared short removals with long ones. So the card’s advice (small, related, announced in advance, brief) rests on practice rather than on a study.

Common mistakes

  • Removing something big or for a long time, like a week without screens. It is hard to keep up, and your child has no fresh chance to do better.
  • Stacking removals during an argument: no tablet, no park, no dessert. Pick one and stop.
  • Taking away something unrelated, or something your child needs, such as food, sleep or a comfort object.
  • Announcing a removal in anger and dropping it later. Only say what you will carry out.
  • Making it your main tool. Keep praise and attention for good behavior far more frequent than removals.

Things you can say

If you two fight over the game again, it goes off for the rest of the afternoon.
You fought over the game, so it’s off until dinner. You can try again after dinner.
Screen time ran past the timer, so no more screens tonight. Tomorrow is a fresh start.
Here’s the game back. Let’s see you take turns.

Solving problems together

When the same conflict keeps coming back, you and your child sit down at a calm time, name the problem, list ideas and pick one to try.

Evidence: Moderate
A parent listens as a nine-year-old explains something at the kitchen table, a sheet of paper and a pencil between them.

How to do it

  1. Pick a calm time, not the middle of a fight. Use it for problems that keep coming back, such as mornings, screen time, homework or sharing a room.
  2. Start with your child’s side. Ask what is hard for them and listen without arguing. Then say your own concern in one sentence.
  3. Name the problem in a way that includes both concerns, for example: you want more time to play, and I need homework done before dinner.
  4. List ideas together without judging them yet. Let your child go first.
  5. Pick one idea you can both live with. You keep the final say on safety and health.
  6. Agree on when you will check how it is going, and adjust the plan together if it isn’t working.
  7. For fights between siblings, be the mediator rather than the judge: help each child say what they want and how they feel, then let them suggest solutions. When Siddiqui and Ross (2004) trained mothers to do this, the mothers could use it, and their children reasoned and talked about feelings more often than children in control families.58

Ages it fits

The trials enrolled children aged 7 to 14,1251 and the mothers who learned to mediate sibling disputes had 5- to 8-year-olds.58 With a preschooler, run a much simpler version: you name the problem and offer two ideas to choose from. Preteens: this becomes the main tool. Let them define the problem and propose the first solution.

Evidence strength: Moderate

Sitting down to solve a problem together can sound soft. In clinic trials it has held up well with children whose behavior problems were serious. Collaborative & Proactive Solutions, a collaborative problem-solving approach, worked as well as standard parent management training in a randomized trial of 134 children aged 7 to 14 with oppositional defiant disorder: about half the children in each treatment no longer met the diagnosis and were much improved, none on the waitlist did, and when Ollendick et al. (2015) checked again 6 months later the gains had held.51 Greene et al. (2004) had earlier tried the approach with 47 children with oppositional defiant disorder who had trouble regulating their emotions, and the improvements matched, and often exceeded, those from parent training.40 Problem-solving skills training also helped in a randomized trial Kazdin et al. (1992) ran with 97 children aged 7 to 13 with severe antisocial behavior, and combining it with parent training helped more.12

Everyday squabbles have a thinner record. When Siddiqui and Ross (2004) trained mothers of 5- to 8-year-olds to mediate their children’s disputes, the mothers could do it, mothers and children both liked it, and the children reasoned, talked about feelings and understood each other’s motives more often than children in control families; the long-term effects are not known.58 Most of this research ran through therapists and involved children with serious behavior problems. Ordinary family conflicts, and children under 5, have been studied much less. One caution: across the 77 evaluations of parenting programs for children aged 0 to 7 that Kaminski et al. (2008) analyzed, the programs that taught parents problem solving were linked with smaller effects.11

Common mistakes

  • Trying to solve it in the middle of a meltdown. Wait until everyone is calm.
  • Coming in with the answer already decided. If your child’s ideas never count, it isn’t solving problems together.
  • Skipping your child’s concern and jumping straight to yours.
  • Agreeing to a plan you won’t keep. Only accept ideas you can live with.
  • Dropping the plan after one bad day. Check in and adjust it together.

Things you can say

I’ve noticed mornings have been hard. What’s tough for you about getting ready?
So you want more time to play, and I need us out the door by 7:30. What could we try?
Let’s write down every idea, even the silly ones.
Which idea should we try this week? Let’s check on Friday how it went.
You both want the swing. What could you do so you each get a turn?

Routines and visual schedules

Doing the hard parts of the day, like mornings and bedtime, the same way every day, with a picture chart your child can follow.

A six-year-old brushes teeth at the bathroom sink while a parent’s hand passes a clean white shirt, a chart of coloured squares stuck to the mirror.

How to do it

  1. Start with the hardest time of day, such as mornings or bedtime, and keep the routine to a few steps.
  2. Do the steps in the same order every day, at about the same time.
  3. Make a picture chart with one drawing or photo per step, and let your child help make it. You can print our routine chart.
  4. Teach it at a calm time: walk through the chart together and practice once or twice.
  5. Point to the chart instead of repeating instructions, and ask what comes next.
  6. For bedtime, keep the last part calm and in the same order each night. Leave screens out of the hour before bed, as the American Academy of Pediatrics advised in its 2016 policy statement on young children and media.148
  7. Notice and praise the steps your child does on their own.
  8. Keep the routine on weekends and trips as much as you can.

Ages it fits

Routines can start in babyhood: the bedtime routine study involved babies and toddlers aged 7 months to 3 years.159 Picture charts suit children who can’t read yet; school-age children can use a written checklist they help make. Preteens run their own morning and homework routines. Your part is the checklist and the follow-up, not the reminders.

Evidence strength: Moderate

Bedtime is where the evidence is most direct. Mindell et al. (2009) randomized 405 mothers and their babies or toddlers either to follow a consistent nightly bedtime routine for 2 weeks or to keep their usual one, and the children in the routine group fell asleep faster and woke less often and for shorter periods; the mothers’ mood improved too.159 If bedtime is still a battle, behavioral approaches in general have good support. Mindell et al. (2006) reviewed 52 treatment studies and found them effective for bedtime problems and night wakings in babies and young children.158

The research on routines in general reaches further back and is looser. Family routines and rituals were related to parenting competence, children’s adjustment and marital satisfaction across the 50 years of research Fiese et al. (2002) reviewed, but those studies measured routines in different ways, relied on convenience samples and did not separate direct from indirect effects, so they show links rather than proof that routines cause the benefits.153 As for the chart itself, we found no studies of picture schedules for typically developing children at home. It is a practical way to make a routine visible, not a tested treatment.

Common mistakes

  • Too many steps. Keep it to a few that your child can remember.
  • Changing the routine every day, or only using it when things go wrong.
  • Turning the chart into nagging. Point to it once, then let your child do the step.
  • Making the chart alone. Let your child choose pictures or stickers so it feels like theirs.

Things you can say

What’s next on your chart?
Teeth are done! Now pajamas. You did that all by yourself.
First shoes, then backpack, then out the door.
Bath, pajamas, teeth, two books, then lights out. Same as every night.

Family meetings

A short, regular family talk where everyone says what went well, raises a problem and helps decide what to try next.

Evidence: Emerging
A family of four sits around the kitchen table on a weekend morning, one child writing on a notepad while the others listen.

How to do it

  1. Pick a regular time, such as Sunday after dinner, and keep it short: 10-20 minutes.
  2. Start with something good. Each person says one thing someone else did well this week.
  3. Take one problem at a time, and let anyone raise a topic, including your child.
  4. Work through it the way you would when solving problems together: everyone says what is hard for them, you list ideas, and you pick one to try.
  5. Give children a real say, but keep the final word on safety, health and money. Giving children a voice is part of what researchers call autonomy support, which is not the same as being permissive.106
  6. Write down what you agreed, put it on the fridge, and check on it at the next meeting. Rules you agree on can go on our family rules poster.
  7. End with something fun: plan an outing, pick a game, or share a snack.

Ages it fits

Fits school-age children best. With a 5- or 6-year-old, keep it to about 10 minutes and one topic. Younger siblings can join for the fun part at the end. Preteens: they can chair the meeting in turn, and it is the place to renegotiate rules and privileges as they earn more freedom.

Evidence strength: Emerging

No study has tested family meetings directly, as far as we could find, so this rating rests on related research.

A meeting borrows two ideas that have been studied. One is solving problems together. Ollendick et al. (2015) ran a randomized trial with children aged 7 to 14 who had oppositional defiant disorder, and a collaborative problem-solving approach worked as well as standard parent management training.51 The other is giving children a real voice: across the 36 studies Vasquez et al. (2016) pooled, parents’ support for their children’s autonomy went with better psychological health and school achievement.197 Those autonomy studies show links, not cause and effect, and none of this research looked at family meetings themselves. Whether regular meetings improve behavior or family relationships is still an open question. Use them as a practical way to plan together, not as a proven treatment.

Common mistakes

  • Turning it into a lecture or a trial about one child’s behavior.
  • Letting it drag on. Stop while it’s still going well.
  • Only meeting when there’s a crisis. Short, regular meetings are easier to keep going.
  • Asking for ideas and then ignoring them. If you can’t accept an idea, explain why.
  • Saving discipline for the meeting. Meetings are for planning; a fight happening right now needs handling right now.

Things you can say

Let’s start with something nice. Who saw someone being kind this week?
Does anyone have something they want to talk about?
So mornings feel rushed. Any ideas? Every idea gets written down.
We’ll try packing bags the night before and see next Sunday how it went.
Meeting’s over. Who picks the game tonight?

Repair after conflict

When you lose your temper or a clash goes badly, you come back once you are calm, own your part, reconnect and plan for next time.

A parent kneels beside the bed with an arm open to hug an eight-year-old sitting on it.

How to do it

  1. Calm down first. If you need a minute, say so and step away, as long as your child is safe.
  2. Come back soon, the same day if you can, and get down to your child’s eye level.
  3. Own your part in a sentence or two, without excuses and without blaming your child.
  4. Reconnect in whatever way your child welcomes: a hug, sitting together, or a few minutes of play.
  5. If a rule was broken, it still stands. Repair mends the relationship; it doesn’t cancel the limit.
  6. Make a plan for next time, for you and for your child.
  7. When your child hurts someone, help them repair too: check on the other person or help fix what broke. Invite a sorry when they are ready rather than forcing one.
  8. If you are losing your temper often, look for support. See what to do in the moment instead and repair after losing your temper.

Ages it fits

Every age. With a baby or toddler, repair is a calm voice, a cuddle and a fresh start. From preschool age you can also name what happened and say sorry in words. School-age children can plan with you what each of you will do differently next time. Preteens: a plain apology with no lecture attached. They notice when you repair, and they copy it.

Evidence strength: Emerging

Tronick (1989) reviewed research on infants and caregivers and described the two using emotional expressions to regulate their interactions with each other; healthy development, the review suggests, goes with interactions in which mismatches are frequently repaired, and poorer development with long stretches of failed interaction and negative emotion.59 That work is about everyday moments with a baby, not about saying sorry after yelling. We found no trial that tests whether a parent’s apology or repair after conflict changes a young child’s behavior, so the rating here rests on related work.

Repairing afterwards is no substitute for holding back the harsh words. The American Academy of Pediatrics, in its 2018 policy statement, advised against verbal abuse such as threatening, insulting or shaming children, and said that yelling at or shaming children is minimally effective in the short term and not effective in the long term.78 Wang and Kenny (2014), in a longitudinal study of 976 families, found harsh verbal discipline at age 13 linked with increases in conduct problems and depressive symptoms over the next year, and parents’ warmth did not weaken that link; it ran the other way too, with misbehavior at 13 linked with increases in parents’ harsh verbal discipline over the next year.79 Those were teenagers, not young children, and the study did not test repair.

Common mistakes

  • Waiting for your child to apologize first. You are the adult, so you go first.
  • Adding a but that hands the blame back, such as saying your child made you yell.
  • Dropping the limit to make up. You can repair and still keep the rule.
  • A long, emotional apology that leaves your child comforting you. Keep it short and about them.
  • Treating repair as a fix for frequent yelling. The goal is fewer blowups; repair is for the ones that still happen.

Things you can say

I yelled at you. That wasn’t OK, and I’m sorry.
I was upset about the mess, but yelling wasn’t the right way to tell you.
Can I have a hug? I love you, even when we’re both upset.
Next time I feel that angry, I’m going to take a break first. What could help you next time?
The toys still need to go away. Let’s do it together.

Sources

The small numbers in the text point to these sources. Each one has a full entry on the Research page.

  1. Kaminski, J. W., Valle, L. A., Filene, J. H., & Boyle, C. L. (2008). A meta-analytic review of components associated with parent training program effectiveness. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 36(4), 567-589. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10802-007-9201-9 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  2. Kazdin, A. E., Siegel, T. C., & Bass, D. (1992). Cognitive problem-solving skills training and Parent Management Training in the treatment of antisocial behavior in children. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 60(5), 733-747. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-006x.60.5.733 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  3. Landry, S. H., Smith, K. E., & Swank, P. R. (2006). Responsive parenting: Establishing early foundations for social, communication, and independent problem-solving skills. Developmental Psychology, 42(4), 627-642. https://doi.org/10.1037/0012-1649.42.4.627 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  4. Leijten, P., et al. (2018). Are relationship enhancement and behavior management “the golden couple” for disruptive child behavior? Two meta-analyses. Child Development, 89(6). https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.13051 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  5. Leijten, P., Gardner, F., Melendez-Torres, G. J., et al. (2019). Meta-analyses: Key parenting program components for disruptive child behavior. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 58(2), 180-190. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaac.2018.07.900 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  6. Dadds, M. R., & Tully, L. A. (2019). What is it to discipline a child: What should it be? A reanalysis of time-out from the perspective of child mental health, attachment, and trauma. American Psychologist, 74(7), 794-808. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000449 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  7. Day, D. E., & Roberts, M. W. (1983). An analysis of the physical punishment component of a parent training program. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 11(1), 141-152. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00912184 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  8. Donaldson, J. M., & Vollmer, T. R. (2011). An evaluation and comparison of time-out procedures with and without release contingencies. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 44(4), 693-705. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2011.44-693 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  9. Donaldson, J. M., Vollmer, T. R., Yakich, T. M., & Van Camp, C. (2013). Effects of a reduced time-out interval on compliance with the time-out instruction: Compliance with time-out. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 46(2), 369-378. https://doi.org/10.1002/jaba.40 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  10. Everett, G. E., Hupp, S. D. A., & Olmi, D. J. (2010). Time-out with parents: A descriptive analysis of 30 years of research. Education and Treatment of Children, 33(2), 235-259. https://doi.org/10.1353/etc.0.0091 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  11. Gershoff, E. T., Grogan-Kaylor, A., Lansford, J. E., Chang, L., Zelli, A., Deater-Deckard, K., & Dodge, K. A. (2010). Parent discipline practices in an international sample: Associations with child behaviors and moderation by perceived normativeness. Child Development, 81(2), 487-502. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8624.2009.01409.x See it on the Research page Back to the text
  12. Greene, R. W., Ablon, J. S., Goring, J. C., Raezer-Blakely, L., Markey, J., Monuteaux, M. C., Henin, A., Edwards, G., & Rabbitt, S. (2004). Effectiveness of collaborative problem solving in affectively dysregulated children with oppositional-defiant disorder: Initial findings. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 72(6), 1157-1164. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-006x.72.6.1157 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  13. Holden, G. W., Gower, T., Wee, S. E., Gaspar, R., & Ashraf, R. (2022). Is it time for “time-in”?: A pilot test of the child-rearing technique. Pediatric Reports, 14(2), 244-253. https://doi.org/10.3390/pediatric14020032 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  14. Kamins, M. L., & Dweck, C. S. (1999). Person versus process praise and criticism: Implications for contingent self-worth and coping. Developmental Psychology, 35(3), 835-847. https://doi.org/10.1037/0012-1649.35.3.835 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  15. Knight, R. M., Albright, J., Deling, L., Dore-Stites, D., & Drayton, A. K. (2020). Longitudinal relationship between time-out and child emotional and behavioral functioning. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 41(1), 31-37. https://doi.org/10.1097/dbp.0000000000000725 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  16. Leijten, P., Gardner, F., Melendez-Torres, G. J., Knerr, W., & Overbeek, G. (2018). Parenting behaviors that shape child compliance: A multilevel meta-analysis. PLOS ONE, 13(10), e0204929. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0204929 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  17. Leijten, P., Thomaes, S., Orobio de Castro, B., Dishion, T. J., & Matthys, W. (2016). What good is labeling what’s good? A field experimental investigation of parental labeled praise and child compliance. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 87, 134-141. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2016.09.008 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  18. Mace, F. C., Page, T. J., Ivancic, M. T., & O’Brien, S. (1986). Effectiveness of brief time-out with and without contingent delay: A comparative analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 19(1), 79-86. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.1986.19-79 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  19. Morawska, A., & Sanders, M. R. (2011). Parental use of time out revisited: A useful or harmful parenting strategy?. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 20, 1-8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10826-010-9371-x See it on the Research page Back to the text
  20. Ollendick, T. H., Greene, R. W., Austin, K. E., Fraire, M. G., Halldorsdottir, T., Allen, K. B., Jarrett, M. A., Lewis, K. M., Whitmore Smith, M., Cunningham, N. R., Noguchi, R. J. P., Canavera, K., & Wolff, J. C. (2015). Parent Management Training and Collaborative & Proactive Solutions: A randomized control trial for oppositional youth. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 45(5), 591-604. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2015.1004681 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  21. Owen, D. J., Slep, A. M. S., & Heyman, R. E. (2012). The effect of praise, positive nonverbal response, reprimand, and negative nonverbal response on child compliance: A systematic review. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 15(4), 364-385. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10567-012-0120-0 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  22. Patall, E. A., Cooper, H., & Robinson, J. C. (2008). The effects of choice on intrinsic motivation and related outcomes: A meta-analysis of research findings. Psychological Bulletin, 134(2), 270-300. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.134.2.270 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  23. Radley, K. C., & Dart, E. H. (2016). Antecedent strategies to promote children’s and adolescents’ compliance with adult requests: A review of the literature. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 19, 39-54. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10567-015-0197-3 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  24. Reynolds, L. K., & Kelley, M. L. (1997). The efficacy of a response cost-based treatment package for managing aggressive behavior in preschoolers. Behavior Modification, 21(2), 216-230. https://doi.org/10.1177/01454455970212005 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  25. Siddiqui, A., & Ross, H. (2004). Mediation as a method of parent intervention in children’s disputes. Journal of Family Psychology, 18(1), 147-159. https://doi.org/10.1037/0893-3200.18.1.147 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  26. Tronick, E. Z. (1989). Emotions and emotional communication in infants. American Psychologist, 44(2), 112-119. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066x.44.2.112 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  27. Sege, R. D., Siegel, B. S., Council on Child Abuse and Neglect, & Committee on Psychosocial Aspects of Child and Family Health (2018). Effective discipline to raise healthy children. Pediatrics, 142(6), e20183112. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2018-3112 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  28. Wang, M.-T., & Kenny, S. (2014). Longitudinal links between fathers’ and mothers’ harsh verbal discipline and adolescents’ conduct problems and depressive symptoms. Child Development, 85(3), 908-923. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12143 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  29. Joussemet, M., Landry, R., & Koestner, R. (2008). A self-determination theory perspective on parenting. Canadian Psychology / Psychologie canadienne, 49(3), 194-200. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0012754 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  30. American Academy of Pediatrics, Council on Communications and Media (2016). Media and young minds. Pediatrics, 138(5), e20162591. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2016-2591 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  31. Fiese, B. H., Tomcho, T. J., Douglas, M., Josephs, K., Poltrock, S., & Baker, T. (2002). A review of 50 years of research on naturally occurring family routines and rituals: Cause for celebration?. Journal of Family Psychology, 16(4), 381-390. https://doi.org/10.1037/0893-3200.16.4.381 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  32. Mindell, J. A., Kuhn, B., Lewin, D. S., Meltzer, L. J., & Sadeh, A. (2006). Behavioral treatment of bedtime problems and night wakings in infants and young children. Sleep, 29(10), 1263-1276. https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/29.10.1263 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  33. Mindell, J. A., Telofski, L. S., Wiegand, B., & Kurtz, E. S. (2009). A nightly bedtime routine: Impact on sleep in young children and maternal mood. Sleep, 32(5), 599-606. https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/32.5.599 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  34. Brummelman, E., Thomaes, S., Overbeek, G., Orobio de Castro, B., van den Hout, M. A., & Bushman, B. J. (2014). On feeding those hungry for praise: Person praise backfires in children with low self-esteem. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 143(1), 9-14. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0031917 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  35. Cameron, J., Banko, K. M., & Pierce, W. D. (2001). Pervasive negative effects of rewards on intrinsic motivation: The myth continues. The Behavior Analyst, 24(1), 1-44. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf03392017 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  36. Deci, E. L., Koestner, R., & Ryan, R. M. (1999). A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 125(6), 627-668. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.125.6.627 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  37. Lepper, M. R., Greene, D., & Nisbett, R. E. (1973). Undermining children’s intrinsic interest with extrinsic reward: A test of the “overjustification” hypothesis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 28(1), 129-137. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0035519 See it on the Research page Back to the text
  38. Vasquez, A. C., Patall, E. A., Fong, C. J., Corrigan, A. S., & Pine, L. (2016). Parent autonomy support, academic achievement, and psychosocial functioning: A meta-analysis of research. Educational Psychology Review, 28(3), 605-644. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-015-9329-z See it on the Research page Back to the text